A government customer may be exempt from a law that still binds its supplier. That was the key distinction in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Baxter Healthcare Pty Limited [2007] HCA 38.
It concerned federal competition law and supplies to State and Territory health authorities.
What happened?
Baxter supplied hospital fluids and kidney dialysis products. It offered products at separate prices or at much lower prices in bundles tied to exclusive supply. The ACCC alleged misuse of market power and exclusive dealing under ss 46 and 47 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). [4]-[11], [26]
The case proceeded on an agreed basis: the health authorities were not carrying on a business when buying these products. The relevant provisions therefore did not bind them. Baxter argued that their immunity also protected its dealings with them. [16], [36]-[37]
What did the High Court decide?
By six judges to one, the Court rejected Baxter’s claimed protection. The five judges in the joint reasons explained that the law could bind one party to a deal without binding the other. A government’s freedom to contract did not give its suppliers a general exemption. [44], [68]-[76], [143], [165]
The Court allowed the ACCC’s appeal and sent the case back to the Full Federal Court. Challenges to the alleged breaches still needed to be decided. This was a ruling on immunity, not a final ruling on every alleged breach. [3], [35], [76]-[78]
What are the limits?
The Court did not abolish all protection for private parties dealing with government. The joint reasons distinguished a government’s general commercial interests from its legal rights. Whether applying a law would take away those rights remained relevant. [59]-[62]
Nor did the Court decide that government purchasing is always exempt, or that bundled discounts are always unlawful. The purchasing authorities’ position was conceded in this case. The competition claims depended on the relevant law and conduct. [16], [19], [77]
What has changed since then?
The legislation is now called the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth). Section 2B still addresses its application to States and Territories. This article explains the 2007 ruling, rather than setting out today’s tests for misuse of market power or exclusive dealing.
In Mayfield Development Corporation Pty Ltd v NSW Port Operations Hold Co Pty Ltd [2026] HCA 12, the High Court applied Baxter to another government transaction. It held that the competition provisions at issue bound the private companies. The decision reinforces the need to examine the law and the particular government rights said to be affected. Gageler CJ at [14]-[16]; Gordon, Gleeson and Beech-Jones JJ at [92]-[94].
What should you ask your lawyer?
Before relying on a government customer’s legal position, ask:
Which laws apply to our own offer and conduct?
What is the legal basis for any claimed exemption?
Would applying the law affect a government legal right, or only its commercial preferences?
A government customer’s exemption is not a supplier’s automatic protection.
Read the 2007 High Court judgment. Paragraph references above refer to that judgment unless stated otherwise.

