An earlier board decision does not necessarily settle the duties that apply to the next step. In ASIC v Lewski, the High Court held that lodging changes to a fund’s constitution and later approving payments could themselves breach duties.
The case was Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Lewski [2018] HCA 63, decided by the High Court of Australia on 13 December 2018. It concerned Commonwealth law governing a registered managed investment scheme.
What happened?
Australian Property Custodian Holdings Ltd ran the Prime Retirement and Aged Care Property Trust. It was the fund’s “responsible entity”: the company responsible for operating the scheme.
In July 2006, four directors approved changes to the fund’s constitution without member approval. These introduced substantial fees for the company, including a listing fee of about $33 million. The fees brought no corresponding benefit to members. [1], [6], [13], [19], [26]
The legal advice left two possible readings of the company’s power to make the changes. It did not say which was correct. The directors gave inadequate consideration to that uncertainty, the fees and the conflict between the company’s interests and members’ interests. [17]-[19], [32]-[34]
In August, the board resolved to lodge the changes with ASIC so they could take effect. Later decisions enabled payment of the listing fee. [22]-[25]
Why did those later steps matter?
The High Court rejected the view that lodging the changes was merely an administrative task. It was intended to give them legal effect. Lodgement did not cure the failure to make valid changes. [58]-[66]
The earlier decision also did not shield the directors’ later conduct. Problems they should have recognised remained unresolved when they voted to lodge the changes. The payment decisions attracted duties too. [67]-[69]
An honest belief that the constitution had been changed was not enough to satisfy the duties in issue. In these circumstances, a reasonable director would have obtained clear legal advice, a court direction or member approval for the payments. [70]-[78]
What was the result?
ASIC succeeded in part. The Court restored findings of duty breaches against four directors, but ASIC failed on a separate allegation that they were knowingly involved in the company’s related-party payment breach. ASIC had not proved the knowledge required for that allegation. [80], [87]-[90]
Mr Clarke’s position was different. ASIC did not challenge the overturning of the findings against him. Penalties and disqualification orders for the other four directors were sent back to the Full Court for determination. [41], [89]-[93]
What can you take from this case?
Before carrying out an earlier decision, check what duties apply to the step you are taking now.
That is a practical lesson from this case. It does not mean every board decision must be reconsidered from scratch. The outcome depended on the unresolved problems, the later acts and the duties governing this scheme.
Questions for your lawyer:
Does this next step need its own check of our powers, duties and conflicts?
What uncertainty in the earlier advice still needs to be resolved?

