Queensland Wire Industries Pty Ltd v The Broken Hill Proprietary Company Ltd [1989] HCA 6; (1989) 167 CLR 177A supplier may say yes, yet set a price that makes buying commercially impossible. That was the problem Queensland Wire faced when it needed steel to compete with BHP.
What happened
Queensland Wire made rural fencing. It wanted to make star picket fence posts too. For that, it needed a steel product called Y-bar.
BHP was Australia’s only Y-bar producer. It used the product to make its own fence posts. It offered to sell Y-bar to Queensland Wire, but at a price designed to make the offer impossible to accept commercially. The trial judge treated this as an effective refusal to supply.
What the High Court decided
The High Court found that BHP had breached section 46 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), as it then applied.
The finding depended on more than the price. BHP had substantial power in the steel products market. It used that power to keep Queensland Wire from competing in fence posts. Mason CJ and Wilson J explained that the absence of other suppliers allowed BHP to withhold Y-bar commercially.
The Court also rejected the view that Queensland Wire had to prove a separate element of morally blameworthy or unfair conduct. The legal question was whether BHP had taken advantage of its market power for a purpose the section prohibited.
Queensland Wire won the appeal. The High Court returned the case to the Federal Court to decide what relief it should receive, including any damages or injunction. It did not itself award compensation.
The law has changed
This is a 1989 decision about an earlier law. Section 46 changed from 6 November 2017. The current provision focuses on whether a corporation with substantial market power engages in conduct with the purpose, effect or likely effect of substantially lessening competition in a market covered by the section. The former requirement to “take advantage” of market power is no longer part of that test. legislation.gov.au
A high price or a refusal to supply does not, by itself, establish a breach. A dispute today needs assessment under the law that applies to the conduct.
Questions for your lawyer
What evidence shows the supplier’s market power and the effect of its terms on competition?
Which version of the law applies to the conduct?
What orders could help, and what would we need to prove to obtain them?
The lesson: assess what supply terms do in practice, not just whether an offer was made.

