Before you buy commercial property, check what protection the sale gives you against building defects. A later claim against the original engineer may fail even if the loss was foreseeable.
Woolcock Street Investments Pty Ltd v CDG Pty Ltd [2004] HCA 16 shows why. The High Court decided the appeal from Queensland on 1 April 2004.
What went wrong?
Woolcock bought a warehouse and office building in Townsville. Its sale contract gave no warranty that the building was free of defects. Nor did it transfer any rights the seller may have had against those responsible for defects. Structural distress later appeared as the foundations, the ground beneath them, or both settled. Woolcock sued the engineering firm and its employee. [1]-[3]
The issue reached the Court on agreed facts and the parties’ pleadings, before a full trial. The question was whether those facts supported a negligence claim. [3]-[7]
Why the claim failed
The High Court dismissed the appeal, six judges to one. The judges in the majority gave different reasons.
In the joint reasons, Gleeson CJ, Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ stressed that foreseeable financial loss was not enough. An important question was whether Woolcock could protect itself from that loss. The Court called this “vulnerability”. [21]-[24]
Woolcock had not shown that it could not obtain contractual protection, such as a warranty or a transfer of the seller’s rights. Nor had it alleged or agreed that the defects could not have been found. These were gaps in the case presented to the Court, not findings that a seller would have agreed to a warranty or that an inspection would have found the defects. [31]-[32]
The original owner’s dealings with the engineers also mattered. It had refused to pay for soil investigations. The joint reasons found no basis for the assumption of responsibility and reliance needed to support Woolcock’s argument by analogy with the earlier house-building case, Bryan v Maloney. [25]-[28]
Kirby J dissented. He considered that Woolcock should have the chance to prove its claim at trial. [175], [191]-[192]
What this means before you buy
The practical lesson is to identify who will bear a defect loss before signing. An inspection and a contractual right serve different purposes: one may reveal a problem; the other may provide a remedy if a problem later emerges. This is a practical inference from the case, not a guarantee that either protection will be available or sufficient.
Ask your lawyer:
What will the proposed inspection cover, and what could it miss?
What warranties or rights against the original builder or engineer can I obtain?
If defects appear later, what legal claim could I bring, against whom, and by when?
The limits of the decision
This case concerned a common law claim for financial loss from defects in the building itself. It did not establish that engineers were immune from all claims or decide whether these engineers had acted negligently. [19]-[25], [35]
It does not settle a NSW owner’s rights today. For a NSW property, ask your lawyer to check any statutory duty or warranty, its application to the work and dates, and the time limits for a claim.

