Home > Case Law Library > Contract > Fexuto Pty Ltd v Bosnjak Holdings Pty Ltd [2001] NSWCA 97Published: 23 January 2025 | Reviewed: 8 October 2026
(3-minute read)
Working in a family company for years can create expectations about your role.
But what did everyone understand that role to include: being consulted, helping run the business, or blocking decisions?
In Fexuto, that distinction mattered to a claim of shareholder oppression, unfair treatment in the way a company’s affairs are run.
How the dispute arose
The Bosnjak family built a bus business. Bob Bosnjak controlled Fexuto, which held two-sevenths of the shares in the family’s holding company.
Bob and his brother Jim had been active in management for many years. Their relationship broke down, and Bob’s influence over daily operations was reduced.
Fexuto brought proceedings alleging oppression. The trial judge found unfair treatment and gave Fexuto the option to have its shares bought at fair value. Fexuto appealed, seeking broader findings and different relief.
Past practice did not establish a lasting veto
Fexuto argued that Bob was entitled to take part in management by consensus. In effect, this meant decisions could not proceed without his agreement.
Spigelman CJ and Fitzgerald JA rejected that claim. They did not find a shared understanding that Bob could continue to block decisions. His ability to get his way over a period did not establish an enduring entitlement.
Priestley JA took a different view, finding that the brothers were entitled to participate in management by consensus. His view on that issue was the minority position.
The majority’s conclusion did not mean that informal understandings were irrelevant. Spigelman CJ recognised that an understanding could be inferred from the circumstances, even without a document or express conversation. The evidence still had to support the particular understanding claimed.
Judgment: [22]-[32], [64]-[79], [657]-[662].
Exclusion from daily management still mattered
Spigelman CJ accepted that there had been an understanding that family members would control the business as executive directors.
He also rejected the argument that Bob’s conduct had made him solely responsible for the breakdown. His exclusion from daily management remained relevant to the assessment of oppression. Fitzgerald JA likewise treated the parties’ shared understanding and their conduct as central to that assessment.
The court examined the whole relationship. Neither family conflict alone nor disappointment about a decision answered whether the company’s affairs had been conducted unfairly.
Judgment: [79]-[104], [649]-[657].
The court refused the preferred remedies
Fexuto wanted a division of the company’s assets or the option to buy the majority shareholder’s shares.
The court refused both. It preserved Fexuto’s option to sell its own shares at fair value, with changes to the valuation arrangements.
Establishing oppression therefore did not secure the business outcome Fexuto preferred.
Judgment: [727]-[731].
Questions to raise with your lawyer
What do the company documents and evidence show about my agreed role?
Does being outvoted differ from being excluded in my circumstances?
What remedy could address the unfairness, and would that outcome suit me?
By Nicky Wang
Principal Solicitor
