Home > Case Law Library > Contract > Masters v Cameron [1954] HCA 72; (1954) 91 CLR 353
High Court of Australia · 30 November 1954 · Appeal from Western AustraliaPublished: 8 January 2025 | Reviewed: 8 October 2026
(3-minute read)
You agree on the price and the main terms. A formal contract will follow.
Can either side still walk away?
In Masters v Cameron, the answer turned on whether the parties had agreed to be bound already or only after signing the formal contract.
The farm sale that did not go ahead
Mrs Cameron signed a document agreeing to sell her farm for £17,500. Mr Masters signed on behalf of himself and his wife. The buyers paid £1,750 towards the purchase.
The document set out the property, price and date for possession. But it also made the sale subject to a formal contract acceptable to Mrs Cameron’s solicitors.
The buyers later refused to proceed. Both sides claimed the money held by the selling agent.
The Supreme Court of Western Australia found a binding contract. The buyers appealed.
What the High Court decided
The High Court held that there was no binding contract of sale.
The formal contract was not merely paperwork recording a finished deal. It could include further terms that Mrs Cameron’s solicitors considered appropriate.
The Court ordered the remaining money returned to the buyers after the agent’s costs, subject to any commission claim the agent was entitled to pursue (see the judgment at 364-367).
A formal contract can serve different purposes
The Court described three situations:
|
What the parties intend |
Legal effect |
|---|---|
|
The deal is final. A later document will record it more fully. |
They are bound already. |
|
All terms are agreed, but carrying out one or more terms must wait for the formal document. |
A binding contract exists, with performance subject to that step. |
|
Neither side will be bound unless and until the formal contract is signed. |
There is no binding contract yet. |
These distinctions explain why “we will sign later” does not, by itself, answer whether a deal exists now (see 360-362).
“Subject to contract” usually means neither side is bound until the formal contract is signed. But those words are not conclusive. Their effect depends on the language and context (see 362-364).
What this means for settlement talks
The same issue can arise when settling a dispute: does the later document record an existing settlement, or must it be signed before there is one?
Later decisions continue to apply this distinction. In Dawson v Centre for Digestive Diseases Pty Ltd (at [45]-[47]), the Fair Work Commission’s Full Bench explained that the ultimate question is whether the evidence, assessed objectively, shows an intention to be bound immediately. The categories provide guidance rather than a mechanical test.
Your private understanding is therefore not enough. What you communicate matters. The High Court has confirmed that intention is assessed objectively from the parties’ words and conduct in their circumstances.
Questions to ask your lawyer
Before accepting proposed terms, ask:
Will acceptance bind me now, or only after a formal document is signed?
What terms remain unresolved?
How should our response make that position clear to the other side?
By Nicky Wang
Principal Solicitor
