A failed class action does not always end a group member’s separate loan defences.
Timbercorp Finance Pty Ltd (in liquidation) v Collins; Timbercorp Finance Pty Ltd (in liquidation) v Tomes [2016] HCA 44 (appeal from Victoria). The case concerned the Victorian group-proceeding scheme in Part 4A of the Supreme Court Act 1986 (Vic).What happened
After the Timbercorp Group collapsed, investors lost a class action about undisclosed risks and misleading statements. Timbercorp Finance later sued Mr and Mrs Collins and Mr Tomes to recover money it said they owed under loan agreements. [1]-[6], [9]-[14].
The borrowers raised defences based on their own dealings. The Collinses argued that no loan had been advanced to them. Mr Tomes argued, among other things, that the person who signed the loan papers for him lacked authority. [23]-[26].
Timbercorp Finance argued that these matters should have been raised in the class action. The borrowers had stayed in that action rather than opting out. [28]-[35].
Why those defences could still be heard
The High Court unanimously rejected the attempt to block the defences. Both appeals were dismissed with costs. [74], [78], [146].
The class action concerned claims based on issues shared by the group. The person bringing it represented members for those claims, not every issue arising from each member’s loan. [47]-[54].
The Court examined what the earlier case covered and whether it was unreasonable to leave these particular issues out. Similarity between the disputes was not enough. In these circumstances, the borrowers did not need to opt out to preserve the defences. Raising them later was not an abuse of the court process. [55]-[68], [73].
What the judgment did not decide
This ruling did not cancel the loans or decide that the defences would succeed. It answered a separate question: whether the borrowers were barred from raising them. [6].
Nor did it give group members a general right to reopen decided claims or save any argument for later. The judgment explained that members were bound by the determination of the claims giving rise to the common questions. Whether an omitted issue can be raised later depends on the circumstances. [27], [52], [56]-[59], [111]-[115].
Ask your lawyer
Which of my claims and defences does this class action cover?
Do my own loan documents or dealings raise issues that need separate advice?
What steps, deadlines and costs should I consider before deciding whether to stay in the group?

