Can you recover money if the contract cannot be enforced?

Before you pursue repayment, or refuse to pay, ask why the contract cannot be enforced. That reason may also affect a claim to recover money outside the contract.

Equuscorp Pty Ltd v Haxton [2012] HCA 7 shows why. The High Court of Australia decided the case on 8 March 2012, on appeal from Victoria.

What happened

Investors borrowed from Rural Finance to prepay management fees in blueberry farming schemes. Rural Finance belonged to the group behind the schemes. No valid prospectus had been registered when the investments were offered, contrary to the Companies Code then in force. [4]-[10]

After the schemes collapsed, Equuscorp acquired the loan agreements and sought repayment. The loans had been held unenforceable because they furthered an illegal purpose. That finding was not challenged in the High Court. [2], [9]-[10], [27]

Equuscorp instead sought restitution: recovery of the money outside the contracts. It argued that the loans had been advanced on the basis that the agreements could be enforced. [28]

Why the claim failed

By five judges to one, the High Court rejected recovery. The legislation protected investors such as these borrowers. Rural Finance was involved in the schemes, and the loans helped further their illegal purpose. Allowing repayment through restitution would defeat that protection. [45], [99]-[111]

All five appeals were dismissed with costs. Equuscorp could not recover the advances from these respondents through its restitution claims.

What this means for your dispute

A claim outside the contract is not an automatic way around the law that prevents enforcement.

But the case does not mean that money paid under every unenforceable contract can be kept. The outcome depends on the relevant law, its purpose and the parties’ roles. French CJ, Crennan and Kiefel JJ expressly rejected a single answer for every case. [34]

There was also a separate issue about which rights Equuscorp had acquired. The judges agreed that a restitution claim of this kind could be transferred, if it existed. They split three-three on whether this deed transferred it. Neither view on the deed was a majority ruling. [53], [64]-[66], [75]-[79], [156]-[161]

Questions for your lawyer

  • Why can this contract not be enforced, and whose interests does the relevant law protect?

  • Does that law also prevent a separate claim to recover the money?

  • If someone bought the debt, what rights did they actually acquire?

Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

Does losing a class action end your loan defence?

Next
Next

When someone at fault does not have to pay your whole loss