When is a late payment fee a penalty?

Paciocco v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2016] HCA 28 (appeal from the Full Federal Court)

A late payment fee may be much higher than the cost of chasing the payment. That gap alone does not make it an unlawful penalty.

In Paciocco v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2016] HCA 28, the High Court of Australia considered what else mattered.

The fees and the challenge

ANZ charged Mr Paciocco late fees on two credit card accounts when he missed the minimum monthly payment. The fee was $35, later reduced to $20. He was charged 26 times. [76]-[85]

The trial judge found that the bank’s actual loss was probably no more than $3 for each late payment. She held that the fees were penalties. The Full Federal Court reversed that decision. [103]-[111]

The High Court dismissed both appeals with costs. A four-judge majority rejected the penalty challenge. Nettle J dissented on that issue. Orders; [2], [69]-[70], [371], [376]

Why the direct cost was not the whole test

The majority’s reasoning looked beyond the expense of contacting a customer. ANZ also had financial interests in timely payment. Late payments could affect its provisions for debts it might not recover and the capital it had to hold against unexpected losses. [58]-[65]

Kiefel J, with French CJ agreeing, asked whether the fee was out of all proportion to the bank’s interest in receiving the minimum payment on time. The customers had not established that it was. [2], [68]-[69]

The question was assessed at the time of the agreement. It was not confined to the loss that happened to follow a particular late payment. [31], [62]; Gageler J at [146]

Nor did ANZ’s failure to calculate the fee as a pre-estimate of damages automatically make it a penalty. The fee’s legal character depended on more than that calculation. [30]; Keane J at [241]-[243]

The decision has limits

Nettle J took a narrower view of the bank’s relevant interests and the evidence. He would have held that the fees were penalties. His conclusion was not the Court’s ruling. [322]-[330], [370]-[371]

The customers’ separate statutory claims also failed. That was an outcome under the laws and circumstances considered in this case. It is not a blanket approval of late fees under today’s consumer laws. [70]; Keane J at [286]-[305]

What to ask your lawyer

Before challenging a fee, ask:

  • What interest does this fee protect, and what evidence supports that explanation?

  • How does its amount compare with that interest when the contract was made?

  • Are there separate rights under the laws that apply to my contract?

These questions help identify the legal issue and the evidence needed to assess it.

Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

Can financial advice be personal despite a general advice warning?

Next
Next

Could a business guarantee put your home at risk?