Westpac Securities Administration Ltd v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2021] HCA 3A caller says the financial advice is general. They then ask what you want to achieve and recommend a step that appears to meet your aims.
In this case, the High Court held that Westpac gave personal advice despite its warning.
What happened
Two Westpac companies contacted existing superannuation members. They encouraged them to move super held elsewhere into their BT accounts. The appeal concerned calls to 14 members.
The callers gave a general advice warning. They then asked about members’ aims, affirmed reasons such as saving fees and making super easier to manage, and offered to arrange the transfers. These exchanges implied a recommendation to proceed. [25]-[27], [43]-[46]
Why the calls amounted to personal advice
The issue was whether a reasonable person in each member’s position might expect Westpac to have taken account of at least one aspect of their aims, financial position or needs. This was the test under s 766B(3)(b) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). [3], [20], [57]
The existing relationship, questions and responses mattered. Together, they could lead members reasonably to expect that the recommendation took account of their stated aims. The opening warning did not undo that impression. [8]-[13]
Westpac did not need a complete picture of a member’s finances for the advice to be personal. Nor did an aim stop being personal because many people shared it. [10]-[11]
The Court dismissed Westpac’s appeal with costs. Its licences did not authorise personal advice about these superannuation products. Westpac accepted that, if the advice was personal, the breaches identified in the reasons followed. [26], [36], [38], [41], [83]
What this decision shows
A general advice warning does not decide the character of the advice that follows.
The whole exchange matters. This decision does not make every sales call personal advice or every warning ineffective. Its conclusion depended on the circumstances of these calls. [5], [8], [72]-[81]
Questions for your lawyer
Could the full conversation amount to personal advice despite the warning?
What records would help establish what was said and the context?
If personal advice was given, what duties and possible remedies apply to my circumstances?

