A company pays $10 million to another company controlled by one of its directors. The terms are not yet finalised. Documents will follow.
In ASIC v Adler [2002] NSWSC 171, this arrangement exposed more than the director receiving control of the funds. Other directors also breached duties through their roles in the payment and the failure to follow the company’s safeguards.
What happened?
HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd, an HIH subsidiary, paid the money to Pacific Eagle, a company controlled by HIH director Rodney Adler. The payment became an investment in a unit trust.
Part of the money bought shares in HIH. Other funds bought investments from Adler Corporation and funded loans to entities associated with Adler. The required investment approval process was bypassed. The Court found that the investment mandate had not been approved and the transactions had not been approved or ratified by the investment committee. [12]-[17], [141], [264]
Why Williams could not simply rely on Adler
HIH chief executive Raymond Williams authorised the payment. He left Adler to follow through with the documents, without ensuring that they would protect the HIH companies’ interests.
The Court found that Williams should have ensured proper safeguards, including independent checks of the investments and approval of the investment mandate. Dealing with a fellow director called for greater scrutiny. Hoping the investment would be profitable did not answer those failings. [403]-[405], [453]
Finance director Dominic Fodera had a different role. He facilitated the payment and failed to take available steps to put the proposal before the investment committee or board. He breached the duty of care and diligence, even though the Court made no finding that he acted dishonestly or for an improper purpose. [512]
What did the court decide?
Among its findings, the Court held that Adler breached duties of care, good faith and proper purpose, and proper use of position. Williams breached duties of care and proper use of position. Fodera breached the duty of care. The March judgment left penalties, compensation and disqualification for separate consideration. [775]-[777]
The appeal matters. In Adler v ASIC [2003] NSWCA 131, the Court of Appeal removed the findings against Adler and Adler Corporation under section 183, concerning use of information. It also required compensation to be recalculated. The remaining declarations and orders stood. Appeal [774]-[775]
What this means for directors
Check the conflict, the terms and the approvals before releasing company money.
That is the practical lesson. It is not a rule that every deal with a director’s company is unlawful, or that every investment loss proves a breach. The current duty of care under section 180 depends on the company’s circumstances and the director’s role and responsibilities. The approvals needed for a particular deal require separate advice.
Questions to ask your lawyer:
Who benefits from this deal, and what interests must be disclosed?
What independent checks and written terms are needed to protect the company?
Which approvals are required, who must give them, and when?

