Low prices and market power

Harm to a rival does not, by itself, prove harm to competition.

A price war can put a business under severe strain. But deciding whether a rival has broken competition law requires more than showing lost sales.

Boral Besser Masonry Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2003] HCA 5 shows why. The High Court decided the case under an earlier law. The current test is explained below.

What happened

Boral Besser Masonry made concrete blocks, bricks and pavers. During a price war in Melbourne, it sold some products below their avoidable cost: costs it could have avoided by not making and supplying them.

The ACCC alleged that Boral had misused market power between April 1994 and October 1996. Its internal plans included an aim to drive a competitor out of the market. Two rivals left, while another, C & M, survived and grew. [Judgment, [18]-[20], [65]-[71], [84]-[86].]

The trial judge dismissed the ACCC’s case. The Full Federal Court reversed that result. Boral then appealed to the High Court. [5]

Why Boral won

By six judges to one, the High Court allowed Boral’s appeal and restored the dismissal of the case.

The former section 46 required substantial market power, use of that power, and a prohibited purpose. An aim to damage rivals could not replace proof of the other elements. [[120]-[123], [168]-[172].]

The majority concluded that Boral lacked the required market power. Customers played suppliers against each other to force prices down. Strong rivals and low barriers to entry constrained Boral. Its financial ability to endure losses did not establish market power. [[138]-[148], [174]-[175], [194]-[197], [318]-[320].]

Kirby J dissented. He considered that Boral’s position, resources and sustained pricing strategy showed market power used for prohibited purposes. [[377]-[398], [444]-[449].]

The law has changed

Section 46 changed on 6 November 2017. Today, section 46 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) prohibits a corporation with substantial market power from conduct with the purpose, effect or likely effect of substantially lessening competition in a relevant market.

The former requirement to “take advantage” of that power is no longer part of this test. Boral therefore does not settle whether similar conduct would be lawful today. [See also the ACCC’s explanation of the change.]

Questions for your lawyer

  • What evidence would show that the rival has substantial market power?

  • How might its pricing affect competition beyond the loss to my business?

  • Which law applies to the dates of the conduct?

Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

Before company money goes to a director’s company

Next
Next

Refusing supply and market power