Flight Centre sold airline tickets. The airlines also sold tickets straight to travellers, sometimes at lower prices. Flight Centre wanted that discounting to stop.
The dispute reached the High Court in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Flight Centre Travel Group Limited [2016] HCA 49, decided on 14 December 2016. It concerned Australian competition law.
What Flight Centre tried to do
Flight Centre promised to beat prices offered by other travel agents and airline websites. Lower direct fares could reduce its margin or cost it a sale.
Between 2005 and 2009, it sent emails seeking to persuade Singapore Airlines, Malaysia Airlines and Emirates to stop selling directly below the fares they published to travel agents. It threatened to stop selling their tickets. The case concerned attempts to induce price fixing. The airlines had not agreed to the unlawful arrangements proposed: [35]-[37], [179]-[180].
Why the agency role did not settle the issue
Flight Centre argued that it could not compete with the airlines because it sold tickets as their agent.
By four judges to one, the High Court allowed the ACCC’s appeal. The relevant competition was for ticket sales, the right to travel, not for operating flights: [25]-[27], [92], [124], [169]-[171].
Kiefel and Gageler JJ stressed two facts. Flight Centre could decide whether to sell an airline’s tickets and set its own prices. It was also free to pursue its own interests in doing so. Those freedoms allowed it to compete with the airlines for customers: [89]-[91].
Nettle J also found competition in ticket sales. Gordon J reached the same result through different reasoning about Flight Centre’s dealings with customers. French CJ dissented: [24], [124]-[132], [152]-[153].
The Court restored the findings against Flight Centre, with changes reflecting that ticket market. It sent the penalty issues back to the Full Federal Court. In 2018, that Court ordered a total penalty of $12.5 million.
What to take from this case
Acting as an agent does not, by itself, rule out competition with the business you represent.
This does not mean every agent competes with its supplier, or every discussion about prices is unlawful. The parties’ rights, freedom to set prices and actual dealings matter: [83]-[89].
Before proposing a pricing arrangement, ask your lawyer:
Do we compete with this supplier for the same customers?
Would our proposal limit the prices it can offer?
What does the current law allow in our circumstances?
This article explains a decision under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), including former s 45A, about conduct in 2005-2009. Advice on a new arrangement must address the current Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth).

