Refusing supply and market power

Losing access to a popular product can hurt a business. That loss alone does not prove a breach of competition law.

In Melway Publishing Pty Ltd v Robert Hicks Pty Ltd [2001] HCA 13, a supplier won its appeal over a refusal to supply. The case applied a legal test that changed in 2017.

Why the supply stopped

Melway published Melbourne’s leading street directory. It used selected wholesalers, each serving an assigned part of the retail market.

Robert Hicks Pty Ltd, trading as Auto Fashions Australia, supplied retailers of automotive parts. Melway ended its appointment and chose another distributor. Hicks then sought 30,000-50,000 directories a year to sell to existing and new customers. Melway refused. [11]-[16]

Hicks won in the Federal Court and survived Melway’s first appeal. The dispute then reached the High Court. [2]

Why Melway won

The former section 46 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 required more than substantial market power and a prohibited purpose. The business also had to take advantage of that power. [6], [44]

Melway’s substantial market power was not disputed. The finding that it meant to prevent Hicks from competing with its distributors also stood. The missing element was proof that it had taken advantage of its power. [3], [37], [68]

The majority looked at Melway’s distribution system as a whole. It had used that system before gaining substantial market power. The majority accepted that it could maintain the system in a competitive market. Refusing Hicks’s order did not necessarily mean losing those sales: existing distributors could make them. [57], [61]-[68]

Four judges allowed Melway’s appeal. Hicks’s application was dismissed, and it was ordered to pay Melway’s costs in the High Court and both courts below. Kirby J dissented. He considered the findings supported a breach. [71], [112]-[114], [120]-[123]; orders 1-4

What changed in 2017

From 6 November 2017, section 46 was replaced. The current provision in the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 prohibits a corporation with substantial market power from conduct with the purpose, effect or likely effect of substantially lessening competition in a market covered by the section.

It no longer requires proof that the corporation “took advantage” of its power. Melway’s result therefore does not settle whether a similar refusal would breach today’s law. Nor did the case give every distribution system a general legal clearance.

Before relying on an old case, check the law that applied then and the law that applies now.

Questions for your lawyer

  • Which version of the law applies to the conduct?

  • What evidence shows substantial market power and harm to competition beyond the loss to my business?

  • What would we need to prove, and what would obtaining that evidence cost?

Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

Low prices and market power

Next
Next

Can an agent also be a competitor? The Flight Centre case