When two newspapers agreed to stay apart

Can competing businesses agree to stay out of each other’s areas? Rural Press Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2003] HCA 75 shows why that can raise a serious competition law issue.

What happened?

The River News began seeking readers and advertisers around Mannum, South Australia. The Murray Valley Standard already served that area. The Standard’s publisher warned that it might start a rival paper in the River News’s home area, the Riverland.

The publishers reached an arrangement: the River News would pull back from Mannum, and the Standard’s publisher would not start a Riverland paper. The River News stopped promoting itself and seeking advertising in Mannum. It did not stop circulating there altogether. [21]-[28], [30]-[35]

What did the High Court decide?

The arrangement had the purpose and effect of substantially lessening competition. The local trade was small, but the River News had brought a real new choice for readers and advertisers. Its retreat largely removed that choice. The Court also held that the arrangement restricted supply to readers and advertisers in Mannum. It did not require proof that the publishers wanted to harm them. [41]-[46], [63]-[72]

The Court upheld the findings against two executives who knew the essential facts and took part. But a majority rejected a separate claim that the Standard’s publisher had misused market power. Kirby J disagreed on that point. Judgment, [47]-[53], [115]-[144] orders)

What should you remember?

An agreement between rivals to stay in their own areas can remove a real choice, even in a small local market.

The case applied the Trade Practices Act 1974 as it then stood. Today’s Competition and Consumer Act 2010, ss 45 and 45AD uses different provisions for agreements that lessen competition and cartel conduct. The 2003 ruling does not decide whether a present-day arrangement breaches those provisions.

Questions for your lawyer:

  • Are we agreeing with a rival about where either business will compete?

  • Does the proposed arrangement restrict supply or divide customers or areas under current law?

Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

Can you owe company duties without a formal title?

Next
Next

Can small print correct a headline price?