Case: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 54, the ads ran in 2010-11, across a change from the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) to the Australian Consumer Law. [9]-[13]TPG advertised unlimited broadband for $29.99 a month. To get it, customers also had to buy TPG home phone line rental for $30 a month. A setup fee and a phone deposit applied too.
The required phone rental appeared with much less emphasis. Could they correct the impression left by the headline price?
What the High Court decided
The High Court majority said the prominent message was crucial in these ads. Many ordinary viewers or listeners would take in their general thrust without studying every detail. The ads themselves drew attention to the attractive price and gave the extra terms less prominence. Knowing that broadband could be sold with phone rental did not mean a person would assume it was bundled here. The majority restored the trial judge's misleading-conduct findings and the $2 million penalty. [45]-[58], [59]-[66]
The issue arose before anyone had to sign up. An ad may lead someone to ask about an offer on a mistaken basis, even if the true terms become clear before a purchase. [47]-[50]
What this does not mean
The court still assesses the whole ad, its audience and its setting. The trial judge found that people would read the revised brochure more closely. Its other information was likely to correct the headline impression. Gageler J dissented: he thought the Full Federal Court could find that most of the ads did not mislead. [25], [51]-[52], [72]-[85]
A headline price can mislead even when the full terms appear elsewhere.
If an advertised price matters to you, ask your lawyer:
Which charges are unavoidable, and would an ordinary person notice them in this ad?
If you publish prices, ask:
Does the first impression match what a customer must actually pay?
The current Australian Consumer Law prohibits misleading conduct and false or misleading price claims in ss 18 and 29(1)(i). This post gives general information, not advice about a particular ad.

