A broken contract can leave a business with equipment, staff costs and little return. Difficulty proving lost profits does not always defeat a claim for money wasted.
In Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd [1991] HCA 54; (1992) 174 CLR 64, the High Court upheld an award based on wasted expenditure.
What happened?
Amann won a three-year contract to fly coastal surveillance for the Commonwealth. It arranged to buy and fit out aircraft for that work. The specially fitted aircraft had a much lower resale value than their cost.
When flights began, Amann had too few aircraft ready and had not met all the contract’s requirements. The Commonwealth tried to end the contract that day. Its notice was invalid. Amann then accepted the Commonwealth’s conduct as bringing the contract to an end. By the High Court appeal, the Commonwealth’s liability was accepted. The dispute concerned damages.¹
Why did future work matter?
Much of the expected commercial benefit lay beyond the first three years. Completing the contract would have left Amann equipped and well placed to compete for further surveillance work. Renewal was not promised.
That advantage was hard to value. Mason CJ and Dawson J took it into account when deciding whether Amann would have recovered its spending. Gaudron J focused on the value the aircraft would have retained for future surveillance work.²
What did the Court decide?
The High Court dismissed the Commonwealth’s appeal by four judges to three. The award remained $5,475,184 in damages, plus interest, making $6,600,207 under the Full Court’s judgment. The damages included net aircraft costs, other start-up costs, staff termination payments and the security deposit.³
The judges gave different reasons. The result does not mean every business can recover all its spending after a breach.
What are the limits?
Damages aim to put the claimant in the financial position it would have occupied if the contract had been performed. They do not insure a losing venture. The value of assets retained and losses that would have occurred anyway must be accounted for.⁴
In Cessnock City Council v 123 259 932 Pty Ltd [2024] HCA 17, the High Court revisited the issue. The joint majority explained that where a breach creates uncertainty in proving loss, reasonable wasted expenditure can help establish that loss. The strength of that assistance depends on the uncertainty caused by the breach. Evidence that spending would not have been recovered can reduce or defeat the claim.⁵
Questions for your lawyer
Which spending was wasted because of the breach, and what value remains?
How did the breach make our expected return harder to prove?
What evidence suggests we would, or would not, have recovered that spending?
Hard-to-prove profits do not always rule out a claim for wasted costs.
Sources
Amann judgment, Mason CJ and Dawson J, reasons [3]-[10].
Amann, Mason CJ and Dawson J [46]-[59]; Gaudron J [13]-[18], [34]-[35].
Amann, Mason CJ and Dawson J [19], [66]; Brennan J [36]; Gaudron J [36]; final order. The other three judges would have reduced the award.
Amann, Mason CJ and Dawson J [23]-[28], [33], [35]; net aircraft value at [9], [19].
Cessnock judgment, Edelman, Steward, Gleeson and Beech-Jones JJ [127]-[128], [165]-[168].

