Can you recover wasted spending after a breach of contract?

Difficulty proving future profit does not always defeat a claim for money already spent. The key is what the breach changed.

In Cessnock City Council v 123 259 932 Pty Ltd [2024] HCA 17, the High Court of Australia considered spending on an aircraft hangar. The case came from New South Wales and was decided on 8 May 2024.

A hangar without the promised lease

The Council agreed to grant a company a 30-year lease at Cessnock Airport, subject to registration of a subdivision. It promised to take all reasonable action to obtain registration by an agreed date. The company spent almost $3.7 million building a hangar while occupying the site under a licence. [62]-[63], [83]-[86]

The Council did not commit the funds needed to meet the subdivision conditions. This breached its promise. The company never received the lease, and the Council later acquired the hangar for $1. [90]-[95], [104]

The trial judge awarded only $1 in damages. The NSW Court of Appeal instead awarded the construction cost plus interest. The High Court unanimously dismissed the Council’s appeal, leaving that award in place. [46], [65]-[67]; formal order

How the court approached the loss

Contract damages generally aim to put the injured party in the financial position it would have occupied if the contract had been performed. They do not provide an escape from a bad bargain. [117]

The four-judge majority explained that the claimant still bears the legal burden of proving loss. But where the breach causes or increases uncertainty about what would have happened, the court can assist with proof. It can infer that reasonable spending in anticipation of, or reliance on, performance would have been recovered. The more uncertainty the breach creates, the stronger that inference may be. [61], [139]

Here, the missing lease and subdivision left major uncertainty about the company’s business prospects. The Council argued that none of the spending would have been recovered. It did not run an alternative case that only part would have been recovered. Its evidence did not defeat the company’s claim. [174]–[186]

The other judges agreed with the result but gave different explanations. This account follows the majority’s approach.

What can limit recovery?

Money spent is not automatically money recoverable. The court must consider all the evidence, including evidence that some or all of the spending would not have been recovered even if the contract had been performed. [139], [165]-[168]

The calculation must account for benefits retained. Unreasonable spending, loss that is too remote and loss that could reasonably have been avoided may also limit an award. [118], [120]

Questions for your lawyer

  • Which spending relied on the promise that was broken, and what records show the link?

  • Did the breach make it harder to prove what would have happened?

  • What evidence could show that some spending would have been lost anyway?

Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

Missed a delay notice: can a builder still get more time?

Next
Next

When can poor financial records justify ending a contract?