A defective house may cost far more to fix than the amount it has lost in market value. Which amount can the owner claim?
In Bellgrove v Eldridge, the High Court upheld damages based on demolition and rebuilding. The work was needed to provide the house promised by the contract and was reasonable in the circumstances.
Case: Bellgrove v Eldridge [1954] HCA 36; (1954) 90 CLR 613 (appeal from Victoria)
What went wrong?
Bellgrove agreed to build Eldridge a house for £3,500. She paid £3,100. The concrete foundations and brickwork mortar departed substantially from the specifications. The house was seriously unstable.
The builder sued for unpaid money. The owner brought her own claim for the defects. His claim failed. She was awarded £4,950, allowing for rebuilding, other losses and deductions. The builder appealed the assessment of her damages. (pp 614-616)
Why did the Court allow rebuilding costs?
The builder argued that damages should reflect the difference between the house’s value as built and its value if built properly.
The Court rejected that approach here. Eldridge had contracted for a house built to agreed plans and specifications. A payment based only on market value would not give her the equivalent of that promised performance. (p 617)
The proposed alternatives to rebuilding were doubtful remedies. The Court would not leave her with the cost of work that might fail to resolve the serious defects. It dismissed the appeal with costs. (pp 619-620)
What limits the claim?
The proposed work must be needed to achieve conformity with the contract. It must also be reasonable.
The Court gave a contrasting example. If a contract required second-hand bricks beneath rendered walls, using first-quality new bricks would not justify demolishing and replacing those walls. That was an illustration, not what happened in this case. Where the necessary work would be unreasonable, damages may instead reflect the loss in value, if any. (pp 618-619)
A defect does not, by itself, justify rebuilding the whole house.
Does a high repair cost make the claim unreasonable?
Not by itself. In Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 8, the High Court applied Bellgrove. It explained that repair costs are not unreasonable merely because they exceed the loss in property value. The contractual promise matters. ([15]–[19])
Questions to ask your lawyer
What expert evidence shows why rebuilding is needed rather than a smaller repair?
Does the proposed work deliver what the contract promised, or include upgrades?
What other losses or deductions affect the amount claimed?
This case concerns damages for breach of a building contract. It does not decide whether you have a valid claim or meet the legal requirements that apply to your dispute.

