Building contract ended early? The agreed price still matters

Mann v Paterson Constructions Pty Ltd [2019] HCA 32 (appeal from Victoria)

Ending a building contract does not give a builder a free hand to reprice past work.

The dispute

The owners hired a builder to construct two townhouses in Victoria for $971,000, including GST. The contract provided for payments when set stages were complete. The owners also asked for changes without following the required written process. [111]-[120]

Each side accused the other of abandoning the contract. The tribunal found that the owners had wrongfully refused to be bound by it. The builder accepted that refusal and ended the contract. [124]-[126], [137]

The builder then sought payment based on the reasonable value of its work, rather than the agreed price. This type of claim is called a quantum meruit. The tribunal awarded a further $660,526.41 after allowing for defects and payments already made. The owners appealed. [135]-[146]

Work with an existing right to payment

All seven High Court judges agreed on this point: where the builder had already earned a contractual right to payment, it could not replace that right with a claim for the reasonable value of the same work. The payment rights under the contract survived termination. [19], [27], [62]-[64], [176]-[179]

Work within an unfinished stage

A majority allowed a different approach for work within a stage where no contractual right to payment had yet arisen. In the circumstances of this case, the builder could seek reasonable payment for that work instead of damages for breach. [61], [105], [174]-[179]

The agreed price still constrained that claim. Gageler J treated the relevant share of the contract price as a ceiling. Nettle, Gordon and Edelman JJ adopted an ordinary limit, while leaving room for cases where applying it would be unconscionable. No such departure was justified here. The other three judges would have rejected restitution altogether. [4], [53], [102]-[105], [215]-[217]

Changes to the agreed work

The builder could not bypass Victoria’s rules for owner-requested changes by claiming their reasonable value. Without compliance, recovery depended on meeting the statutory exception. The tribunal had not assessed that exception. [152]-[161]

The High Court allowed the appeal and sent the matter back to the tribunal. It did not decide the final amount payable. [222]; orders 1-2

Questions for your lawyer

Before ending a contract or responding to a final bill, ask:

  • Do we have grounds to end the contract, and what notices are required?

  • Which payment rights have already arisen, and what work remains within unfinished stages?

  • What is the legal basis for each amount claimed, and how do the agreed rates and earlier payments affect it?

  • Were changes properly recorded and approved under the law that applies?

This case concerned a builder ending the contract after the owners’ wrongful refusal to perform. It does not make payment for unfinished work automatic. The contract, reason for termination and applicable state law matter. The variation rules discussed were Victorian law, not NSW law.

Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

Building defects: check your right to recover repair costs

Next
Next

When can an owner claim rebuilding costs?