In Bryan v Maloney [1995] HCA 17, a later buyer recovered damages from the builder for hidden defects in a house. She had no building contract with him. The decision depended on the kind of loss and the relationship between the parties.
Cracks appeared after the purchase
Mr Bryan built a house in Launceston in 1979. Mrs Maloney became its third owner in 1986. She inspected it three times before buying and saw no cracks. About six months later, cracks began to appear. The footings were too weak for the seasonal changes in the clay soil.
By the High Court appeal, the builder’s negligence, its effect and the amount of loss were no longer disputed. The remaining issue was whether he owed this later buyer a duty of care: a legal duty to take reasonable care to avoid the loss she suffered. (Joint reasons, [1]-[5].)
Why the buyer succeeded
The High Court of Australia, hearing an appeal from Tasmania, ruled for Mrs Maloney by a 4-1 majority. It dismissed the builder’s appeal with costs.
Mason CJ, Deane and Gaudron JJ stressed that a house may change hands before hidden defects emerge. A later buyer would often lack the skill and opportunity to test its footings. The builder’s responsibility and the buyer’s likely reliance supported a duty to avoid this loss. Toohey J reached the same result in separate reasons. Brennan J dissented. (Joint reasons, [18]-[19], [24]; Toohey J, [27]-[29]; Brennan J, [47]-[48].)
The claim concerned the fall in the house’s value when the faulty footings became apparent through damage to the house. The case proceeded on the basis that the necessary repair cost measured that loss. (Joint reasons, [3]-[5].)
What this means today
This was a decision about a dwelling and a particular kind of loss. It did not establish a right to recover the cost of every building defect. (Joint reasons, [23].)
Later High Court decisions, Woolcock and Brookfield, require attention to whether a buyer could protect themselves against the financial loss, including through contractual rights. Simply relying on a builder to do the work properly is not enough. (Woolcock [2004] HCA 16, [23]-[24]; Brookfield [2014] HCA 36, [55]-[58].)
Having no contract with the builder does not, by itself, rule out a claim.
Questions for your lawyer
What legal duty would support my claim against the builder?
What evidence shows whether I could protect myself against this loss when I bought?
Which statutory rights and time limits need to be checked for my property?

