A building contract may say that a claim must be paid if no payment certificate is issued. But what had to happen before that duty arose?
In Brewarrina Shire Council v Beckhaus Civil Pty Ltd [2003] NSWCA 4, the NSW Court of Appeal considered that question under clause 42.1 of AS2124-1992. Its decision turned on the evidence and information required to support the claim.
Why the payment claim reached court
Beckhaus claimed $702,678.45 from the Council. The superintendent, the person appointed under the contract to assess payment claims, did not issue a payment certificate within 14 days. After 28 days had passed, Beckhaus relied on the clause requiring payment where no certificate had been issued. It obtained judgment without a full trial. [2]-[6]
The Council appealed. It argued that Beckhaus first had to provide evidence of the amount due and information the superintendent had reasonably required. Whether the information supplied met the contract was still disputed. [6], [9]-[12]
The supporting material mattered
By a two-to-one majority, the Court held that the required evidence and information had to be provided before the superintendent was obliged to issue a payment certificate. The clause requiring payment without a certificate was itself subject to the contract’s other terms. [1], [14], [42]
The timing of a request also mattered. Ipp JA said the additional information had to have been required before the payment claim was delivered. A later request did not qualify under this part of the clause. [44]
Young CJ in Eq dissented. He considered that the clause’s purpose, keeping funds flowing while work continued, favoured a duty to assess the claim without that prior condition. [70]-[80], [88]
What the Council won
The Court set aside the summary judgment and allowed the Council to defend the claim. It ordered Beckhaus to pay the costs of the summary judgment application and appeal. It did not finally decide how much the Council owed. [45], [59]
The dispute continued. In a later appeal, the Court held that the information condition had been met by 27 May 2002: Brewarrina Shire Council v Beckhaus Civil Pty Ltd [2005] NSWCA 248 at [200]-[210].
The practical lesson
Before relying on a missed contractual deadline, check what had to happen first.
Keep the claim, supporting records and information requests together. They help show what was required, when it was requested and what was supplied. That is a practical lesson from the dispute, rather than a separate rule laid down by the Court.
This case concerned a particular contract clause. Statutory security of payment rights require separate analysis. In Clarence Street Pty Ltd v Isis Projects Pty Ltd [2005] NSWCA 391 at [1]-[3] and [60]-[63], the Court distinguished statutory rights from contractual requirements.
Questions for your lawyer
What evidence must support our claim, and what further information was requested before we sent it?
Are we relying on the contract, security of payment legislation, or both?
Would the proposed court step finally resolve payment, or leave factual issues for trial?

