Probuild Constructions (Aust) Pty Ltd v Shade Systems Pty Ltd [2018] HCA 4 (NSW security of payment law)A legal error may not be enough to overturn a NSW construction payment ruling. The type of error matters.
What happened?
Shade Systems supplied and installed external louvres for an apartment project. It claimed a progress payment from Probuild. Probuild refused to pay, saying it was owed a larger sum for delay. An adjudicator rejected that delay claim and awarded Shade Systems $277,755.03, including GST. [19]-[22]
Probuild persuaded the Supreme Court to set the ruling aside for legal errors. The Court of Appeal reversed that result. Probuild then appealed to the High Court. [23]-[25]
Why did Probuild lose?
The High Court unanimously dismissed the appeal. Under the NSW Act, the Supreme Court could not set aside the adjudication for a legal error shown in the written record if that error was within the adjudicator’s authority. The legal term is a non-jurisdictional error. [2], [35], [54]-[55], [109]
The scheme aimed to keep construction payments moving. It provided a fast payment process while leaving the final contract dispute to be resolved separately. Allowing court review for this kind of error would undermine that purpose. [37]-[48]
What could still be challenged?
Review for jurisdictional error remained available. This concerns the legal limits of the adjudicator’s powers. It differs from getting a question wrong while acting within those powers. In Probuild’s High Court appeal, the error was accepted to be non-jurisdictional. [29]-[30], [50], [79]
That distinction requires legal analysis. Calling an error serious or obvious does not, by itself, make it jurisdictional. [51]
Was the contract dispute over?
No. The adjudication did not finally decide the parties’ contractual rights. Those rights could still be pursued in separate proceedings. A court must account for payments already made. It may order repayment where appropriate. [46]-[51]
That carried a practical risk: the party receiving too much might later be unable to repay it. Preserving a right to recover money did not guarantee recovery. [51]
Questions for your lawyer
Is the alleged error within the adjudicator’s powers, or does it affect those powers?
What payment or enforcement steps apply while a challenge is considered?
What would separate contract proceedings cost, and could any repayment be recovered?
This article explains a decision under NSW legislation. It is general information, not advice about a particular payment claim or another jurisdiction.

