Can you challenge a construction payment ruling for a legal error?

Probuild Constructions (Aust) Pty Ltd v Shade Systems Pty Ltd [2018] HCA 4 (NSW security of payment law)

A legal error may not be enough to overturn a NSW construction payment ruling. The type of error matters.

What happened?

Shade Systems supplied and installed external louvres for an apartment project. It claimed a progress payment from Probuild. Probuild refused to pay, saying it was owed a larger sum for delay. An adjudicator rejected that delay claim and awarded Shade Systems $277,755.03, including GST. [19]-[22]

Probuild persuaded the Supreme Court to set the ruling aside for legal errors. The Court of Appeal reversed that result. Probuild then appealed to the High Court. [23]-[25]

Why did Probuild lose?

The High Court unanimously dismissed the appeal. Under the NSW Act, the Supreme Court could not set aside the adjudication for a legal error shown in the written record if that error was within the adjudicator’s authority. The legal term is a non-jurisdictional error. [2], [35], [54]-[55], [109]

The scheme aimed to keep construction payments moving. It provided a fast payment process while leaving the final contract dispute to be resolved separately. Allowing court review for this kind of error would undermine that purpose. [37]-[48]

What could still be challenged?

Review for jurisdictional error remained available. This concerns the legal limits of the adjudicator’s powers. It differs from getting a question wrong while acting within those powers. In Probuild’s High Court appeal, the error was accepted to be non-jurisdictional. [29]-[30], [50], [79]

That distinction requires legal analysis. Calling an error serious or obvious does not, by itself, make it jurisdictional. [51]

Was the contract dispute over?

No. The adjudication did not finally decide the parties’ contractual rights. Those rights could still be pursued in separate proceedings. A court must account for payments already made. It may order repayment where appropriate. [46]-[51]

That carried a practical risk: the party receiving too much might later be unable to repay it. Preserving a right to recover money did not guarantee recovery. [51]

Questions for your lawyer

  • Is the alleged error within the adjudicator’s powers, or does it affect those powers?

  • What payment or enforcement steps apply while a challenge is considered?

  • What would separate contract proceedings cost, and could any repayment be recovered?

This article explains a decision under NSW legislation. It is general information, not advice about a particular payment claim or another jurisdiction.

Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

Can retention money depend on the whole project being finished?

Next
Next

Building defects: Can a builder pass responsibility to others?