Maxcon Constructions Pty Ltd v Vadasz [2018] HCA 5
(appeal from South Australia)A subcontract may say that retention money will be released only after the whole project reaches a milestone. In Maxcon, that condition could not justify deducting retention from a progress payment.
What held up the money?
Maxcon engaged Mr Vadasz to design and build piling for an apartment development. Their subcontract required cash retention of 5% of the contract sum as security. [6]-[7]
Half was to be released 90 days after a defined occupancy approval milestone. The rest was to be released after 365 days. That milestone concerned the whole development, not just the piling. [8]-[9], [18]-[20]
When Mr Vadasz claimed a progress payment, Maxcon deducted retention. An adjudicator decided that Maxcon had no right to make that deduction. Maxcon challenged the decision and ultimately appealed to the High Court. [10]-[15]
Why did the condition fail?
Section 12 of the South Australian security of payment Act made “pay when paid” provisions ineffective in relation to payments for construction work. The definition went beyond waiting for someone else to pay. It also covered payment obligations or due dates that depended on the operation of another contract. [12], [16]-[17]
Here, the occupancy certificate required the builder to certify compliance with documents that included the head contract, the agreement between Maxcon and the landowner. The release dates therefore depended on completion of that contract. [21]-[25]
The majority held that these retention provisions fell within the statutory definition. Maxcon could not deduct the retention sum from the progress payment. Its appeal was dismissed. [25]-[30], [41]
What does the decision leave open?
The Court did not ban retention money or decide that every occupancy condition is ineffective. Its reasoning turned on the terms of this subcontract, the approval requirements and section 12.
The Court also confirmed limits on judicial review under that statutory scheme. An error of law within an adjudicator’s authority was not enough to have the determination quashed. Review for jurisdictional error remained available. [5], [34]-[39], [41]
This case concerned South Australian law. For another project, the applicable law, contract terms and payment claim need their own review.
What should you ask your lawyer?
Check what must happen before retention is released, not just how many days you must wait.
Does release depend on my work, or on performance of another contract?
Can this condition lawfully delay payment under the law applying to this project?
What payment claim steps and deadlines should I check now?

