A small fall in market value does not always mean a small damages claim.
The contract may protect a right to have the property kept as agreed.
Case: Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 8 (The dispute concerned a lease of premises in Victoria).The foyer was changed without consent
In Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 8, a tenant replaced an office building’s foyer without the landlord’s consent. The lease required prior written approval for substantial changes. The tenant knew approval was needed and had not been given. [1]-[3], [7]
The trial judge awarded $34,820, mostly reflecting the difference in the property’s value. The Full Federal Court increased the award to $1.38 million: $580,000 to restore the foyer and $800,000 for rent lost during restoration. The High Court dismissed the tenant’s appeal with costs. [5], [27]
What the contract protected
The landlord had a contractual right to preserve the premises without unapproved changes. A payment based only on the fall in market value would not give it the equivalent of what had been promised. Restoration costs did. [12]-[15]
The building’s use as a commercial investment did not remove that right. The award compensated for the breach; it was not a penalty for the tenant’s conduct. [13]-[16]
Restoration costs have limits
The work must be necessary to achieve what the contract required, and it must be reasonable. A restoration cost above the fall in market value is not, for that reason alone, unreasonable. [17]-[20]
The decision does not settle every question about the amount recoverable. The Court said a properly supported reduction for getting something newer or better might have had merit, but the tenant had not sought one. It also left potential issues about the date used to price the loss unresolved because the tenant had not raised them. [24]-[26]
Questions for your lawyer
What did the contract require, and which measure of damages reflects that promise?
What evidence would show that the proposed restoration is necessary and reasonable?
Could lost rent, an allowance for getting something newer or better, or the timing of the work change the amount?

