A contractor may be behind schedule. That does not, by itself, settle whether the other party can take over the work.
In Renard Constructions (ME) Pty Ltd v Minister for Public Works (1992) 26 NSWLR 234, the NSW Court of Appeal examined how a power to take over work had been used.
What went wrong?
Renard was building two pumping stations. The Minister issued a notice requiring it to explain why the remaining work should not be taken away or the contract cancelled. This is called a show cause notice.
Renard accepted that it was in default. But the Minister had also supplied some materials late. The arbitrator found that Renard was entitled to more time than it had been given.
After the notice, Renard increased its workforce, worked longer hours and brought in an experienced foreman. The officer who decided to take over the work did not have that full picture. His decision relied on misleading, incomplete and prejudicial information.[1]
What did the Court decide?
The Court restored the arbitrator’s award in Renard’s favour. The Minister’s takeover was not justified under the contract and amounted to repudiation: conduct entitling Renard to accept that the contract was at an end.
The judges agreed on the result but took different routes. Priestley and Handley JJA held that the power under clause 44.1 had to be exercised reasonably. Meagher JA rejected that implied requirement. He found that the decision-maker’s misunderstanding prevented him from reaching the satisfaction the clause required.[2]
How far does the case go?
The decision concerned a particular contract clause. It does not mean every contract can be ended only if a court considers that reasonable.
Priestley JA also discussed good faith more widely. That discussion was not a ruling by the whole Court that every Australian contract contains the same duty. The NSW Court of Appeal later described it as observations beyond the reasoning needed for the decision.[3]
The practical lesson is to check both the clause and the facts before acting on an alleged default.
Questions for your lawyer
What does our clause require before work can be taken away?
Have any extensions of time, causes of delay or recent improvements been missed?
What could happen if our proposed action is outside the contract?

