Home > Case Law Library > Contract > Brunninghausen v Glavanics [1999] NSWCA 199Published: 17 January 2025 | Reviewed: 8 October 2026
(3-minute read)
A company’s accounts may help you value your shares. They may reveal nothing about talks to sell the business.
In this case, a director bought another shareholder’s shares without disclosing those talks. The Court held that, in the circumstances, he had breached a duty owed to the seller.
Two deals were taking shape
Max Brunninghausen ran a ski equipment business. He held five-sixths of the company’s shares. His brother-in-law, Michael Glavanics, held the rest.
Their relationship had broken down. Glavanics remained a director in name, but no longer took part in running the company or received information about its affairs.
While negotiating to buy Glavanics’ shares, Brunninghausen began separate talks with outside buyers interested in the company’s business. He did not tell Glavanics.
On 8 December 1987, Glavanics agreed to sell. The deal included $30,000 cash, $15,000 in stock and the release of disputed debts. The next morning, Brunninghausen agreed with the outside buyers on a price of $2.15 million for goodwill. A binding business sale agreement came later.
[6]-[22], [37]-[39]
The missing information mattered
The issue was not simply whether Glavanics should have examined the accounts.
The trial judge found that an inspection of the accounting records would not have revealed the pending sale talks. Brunninghausen knew about them through his control of the business. Glavanics depended on him for that information.
[46]-[51]
Nor did the absence of an agreed sale price on 8 December excuse the silence. By then, the outside buyers’ interest had materially changed the situation. The Court held that Brunninghausen could not buy Glavanics’ shares without disclosing those negotiations.
[37]-[39]
A duty despite the loss of trust
Directors generally owe their duties to the company. That does not automatically give each shareholder a personal claim.
Here, however, Brunninghausen was the only effective director. There was just one other shareholder, who had no practical access to the sale talks. Brunninghausen’s position gave him a special advantage when buying that shareholder’s shares.
The Court upheld a fiduciary duty, a duty of loyalty, requiring disclosure of those negotiations. The lack of personal trust between the men did not prevent that duty from arising. This was a decision about their particular circumstances, not a blanket rule for every share sale.
[54]-[58], [97]-[106], [113]
Liability stood. Compensation needed a proper hearing
The Court upheld the finding of breach but set aside the $300,000 compensation award.
Brunninghausen had not received a proper opportunity to call evidence and answer the compensation claim. The Court sent that issue back for an inquiry. It did not finally determine the amount payable.
[117]-[123]
Before agreeing to sell
A valuation based on accounts may miss a deal already taking shape.
Questions to raise with your lawyer:
What should we ask about current offers or sale talks before I agree to a price?
In these circumstances, does the director buying my shares owe me a duty of disclosure?
By Nicky Wang
Principal Solicitor
