Does trust in business create a duty of loyalty?

Home > Case Law Library > Contract > Hospital Products Ltd v United States Surgical Corporation [1984] HCA 64
High Court of Australia · 25 October 1984 · Appeal from New South Wales

Published: 16 January 2025 | Reviewed: 8 October 2026
(3-minute read)

Trusting a business partner does not, by itself, mean they owe you a legal duty of loyalty.
In this case, dishonest conduct led to liability for breach of contract, but did not establish a fiduciary relationship.

What happened?

United States Surgical Corporation made surgical stapling products. A company controlled by Alan Blackman became its exclusive Australian distributor.

Blackman had a secret plan. His company would develop competing products and take over the Australian market for the manufacturer’s goods.

During the distributorship, the company delayed filling orders so it could supply its own products instead. Customers were misled into believing those products were made under an arrangement with the manufacturer (Judgment from Gibbs CJ at [3]-[6]).

Why the type of duty mattered

The manufacturer sought more than damages for breach of contract. It claimed a constructive trust over business assets, a remedy that would require those assets to be held for its benefit.

Its case relied on an alleged fiduciary duty. This is a duty of loyalty that restricts conflicts of interest and unauthorised gains within the matters it covers.

The key question was whether that duty existed in the first place (Judgment from Gibbs CJ at [27]; Mason J at [10]).

What the High Court decided

Gibbs CJ, Wilson J and Dawson J formed the majority on the orders. They rejected the fiduciary claim and held that the manufacturer was entitled to damages for breach of contract. The matter returned to the Supreme Court to assess those damages.

The parties had made a commercial agreement under which the distributor bought and resold goods for its own profit. Its obligation to use its best efforts did not require it to put the manufacturer’s interests ahead of its own in every conflict.

The judges took different paths. Mason J found a limited fiduciary duty. Deane J did not, but supported limited equitable relief on another basis. Neither approach determined the final orders.

Judgment: Gibbs CJ at [38]–[44]; Wilson J at [5]–[7]; Mason J at [93]–[94], [117]; Deane J at [11]–[12]; Dawson J at [76]; formal orders.

What this means for a business agreement

The decision does not mean commercial relationships can never carry fiduciary duties. The terms of the agreement, the role undertaken and the surrounding facts matter.

In a later case, the High Court confirmed that fiduciary duties must fit the contract. They cannot be added in a way that changes its intended operation: John Alexander’s Clubs Pty Ltd v White City Tennis Club Ltd [2010] HCA 19 at [91].

The practical step is to identify the protection you need before a dispute arises. If competition, customer relationships or use of business information matters, ask whether your agreement deals with it expressly.

Questions to ask your lawyer

  • What must the other party do under our agreement?

  • Do they owe a duty of loyalty for any part of their role?

  • What remedy could we seek if they breach those duties?

By Nicky Wang
Principal Solicitor
Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

Selling shares to a director: What should they disclose?

Next
Next

Misleading conduct: Can you prove it caused your loss?