Home > Case Law Library > Contract > Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of NSW HCA 24; (1982) 149 CLR 337Published: 21 January 2025 | Reviewed: 8 October 2026
(3-minute read)
Both sides may expect a project to run a certain way. But have they agreed who bears the cost if that expectation proves wrong?
The work could not continue as planned
Codelfa agreed to build railway tunnels within 130 weeks. The work required three shifts a day, six days a week, with no restriction on Sunday work.
Both parties believed the work was protected from court orders stopping noise and nuisance. That belief was wrong.
Residents obtained injunctions restricting the work. Codelfa could no longer follow the planned schedule and incurred extra costs (Mason J, pp 359-363).
The Court would not add the missing protection
Codelfa argued that the contract contained an unwritten term requiring extra time or compensation if injunctions disrupted the work.
The High Court rejected the proposed implied term.
Mason J explained the central difficulty: several arrangements could have dealt with the risk. The parties might have agreed on compensation, a different price or some other solution. There was no clear basis for choosing one and treating it as their agreement (Mason J, pp 355-356).
A reasonable term is not enough
For a term to be implied into this contract, it had to:
be reasonable and fair;
be necessary to make the contract work;
be so obvious that it went without saying;
be capable of clear expression; and
fit with the contract’s express terms.
These requirements concern a term implied from the particular contract and its circumstances. They do not describe every way the law supplies contractual obligations (Mason J, pp 345-347).
Frustration raised a different question
Codelfa also argued that the injunctions had made performance radically different from what the parties had contracted for. This is the basis of the legal doctrine called frustration.
That question differs from asking whether an extra term belongs in the contract. Frustration concerns whether further performance is discharged, rather than whether the existing bargain should include added protection.
The Court remitted the frustration claim to the arbitrator for decision. It did not award Codelfa compensation under the proposed implied term (Mason J, pp 357, 363-367; formal orders).
Ask what happens if the assumption is wrong
Before signing a contract, ask your lawyer:
Which assumptions does the price or deadline depend on?
Who bears the risk if an assumption fails?
Does the contract provide extra time, payment or a right to end it?
By Nicky Wang
Principal Solicitor
