Home > Case Law Library > Contract > Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd [2004] HCA 52
High Court of Australia, on appeal from New South WalesPublished: 20 January 2025 | Reviewed: 8 October 2026
(3-minute read)
A form headed “Application for Credit” may do more than set payment terms. It may also decide who bears the loss if something goes wrong.
In Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd [2004] HCA 52, unread terms on the back of a signed form helped defeat a claim for damaged goods.
What was signed?
Alphapharm supplied flu vaccines. Another company, Richard Thomson, arranged storage and transport with Finemores, later known as Toll.
Richard Thomson’s representative signed a credit application. Above his signature, the form asked him to read the conditions on the back. He did not.
Those conditions excluded the carrier’s liability for loss or damage, including negligence. They also placed responsibility for insurance on the customer. [17]-[20]
What happened when the vaccines were damaged?
Some vaccines were exposed to temperatures below the required minimum during storage or transport.
Alphapharm obtained a judgment for $683,061.86. But the High Court overturned that result. The exclusion clause applied, and Alphapharm had to repay the money with interest and bear the costs ordered against it. [2], [27]-[28], [82]-[83]
Why did the unread terms count?
The Court held that the conditions formed part of the contract.
The representative knew he was signing a document intended to affect legal relations. He had not been misled or prevented from reading it. Signing without reading did not require the carrier to prove that it had separately drawn the terms to his attention. [38]-[39], [54]-[57]
Alphapharm had not signed that form itself. However, it had authorised Richard Thomson to arrange the services. On the evidence, that authority extended to accepting the carrier’s standard terms. [80]-[82]
Does a signature settle every dispute?
No. The Court recognised that matters such as misrepresentation, duress, mistake and available statutory relief can affect the result.
This case did not establish that every signed term is enforceable. It established that failing to read the terms was insufficient in these circumstances. [49], [54], [57]
Before you sign
Check the whole document, including terms on the back or in attachments. Look for clauses about liability, insurance and whose interests the signer represents.
Ask your lawyer:
Could this form exclude a claim if the supplier causes damage?
Who needs to insure against that loss?
If someone contracts for us, what terms can they accept?
By Nicky Wang
Principal Solicitor
