Home > Case Law Library > Contract > Gambotto v WCP Ltd [1995] HCA 12; (1995) 182 CLR 432
High Court of Australia · Appeal from the Supreme Court of NSWPublished: 13 January 2025 | Reviewed: 8 October 2026
(3-minute read)
A fair price does not always make a forced sale lawful.
In Gambotto v WCP Ltd, the High Court struck down a change to a company’s rules that would let the majority buy out shareholders who wanted to stay.
What happened?
Related companies held about 99.7% of WCP’s shares. Two minority shareholders did not want to sell. The compulsory acquisition provisions then available did not allow their shares to be acquired in these circumstances.
WCP changed its rules, then called its “articles of association”. The new rule allowed a shareholder holding at least 90% of the shares to force the remaining shareholders to sell for $1.80 a share.
An independent expert had valued the shares at $1.365 each. The two shareholders accepted that valuation as fair, but challenged the power to make them sell (at joint judgment, [2]-[6]).
Why did the challenge succeed?
Four judges, Mason CJ, Brennan, Deane and Dawson JJ, held that this kind of change needed both a proper purpose and fairness.
A proper purpose could include protecting the company from significant harm caused by a shareholder’s continued membership. For example, a shareholder might compete with the company, or their continued ownership might prevent compliance with rules governing its business.
Here, the reasons were tax savings and administrative benefits from full ownership. Those benefits alone did not justify the change. The joint judgment held the new rule invalid because it lacked a proper purpose (at joint judgment, [26]-[28], [33]-[34]).
Fairness includes the process
The joint judgment explained that fairness involves both how the acquisition is carried out and its terms.
Relevant information must be disclosed. The judges also indicated that an independent valuation would presumably be required. A fair price depends on more than the current market price: assets, dividends and the company’s likely future can also matter.
Those supporting the forced acquisition bear the burden of proving that the change has a proper purpose and is fair (at joint judgment, [29]-[32]).
Did all five judges agree?
All five agreed that the change was invalid, but McHugh J took a different path.
He accepted that the tax savings could justify the acquisition if it was otherwise fair. However, the company had not proved fair dealing and full disclosure.
The appeal succeeded with costs (McHugh J, [23]-[25]; joint judgment, [37]).
What does this mean today?
Gambotto concerned changing a company’s rules to create a forced-sale power. It does not give every shareholder an absolute right to refuse every compulsory acquisition.
The current Corporations Act 2001 (Chapter 6A) contains statutory acquisition procedures with their own conditions and protections. These include procedures following takeover bids and a general acquisition procedure for qualifying 90% holders (see ASIC’s guide to compulsory acquisitions and buyouts).
Later decisions have also examined the limits of Gambotto. In Arakella Pty Ltd v Paton [2004] NSWSC 13, the Court distinguished a trust restructure involving court supervision and equal treatment of all unitholders. The legal route and ownership structure therefore matter.
Questions to ask your lawyer
What legal power is being used to require the sale?
Do the company’s existing rules allow it, or are they being changed?
What information and valuation support the proposal?
What rights do I have to object, and when must I act?
By Nicky Wang
Principal Solicitor
