Can a director issue shares to change who controls a company?

Home > Case Law Library > Contract > Whitehouse v Carlton Hotel Pty Ltd [1987] HCA 11; (1987) 162 CLR 285
High Court of Australia · 7 April 1987 · Appeal from Queensland

Published: 14 January 2025 | Reviewed: 8 October 2026
(3-minute read)

A director may have power to issue shares.
That does not mean they can use it to favour one group of shareholders over another.

In Whitehouse, a father allotted shares to his sons to shift future voting control away from his former wife. The High Court majority held that the allotment was made for an improper purpose.

What happened?

Charles Whitehouse controlled a family hotel company. Its rules gave him the board’s powers while he remained its permanent governing director.

Different classes of shares carried different rights. Charles held the shares with current voting rights. His former wife held shares that could carry votes after his death. Their children held shares carrying financial rights but no votes.

After the marriage ended, the sons sided with Charles and the daughters with their mother.

Charles allotted two additional deferred-voting shares to each son. His purpose was to dilute his former wife’s potential voting power and secure a future majority for those he favoured.

Later, Charles fell out with his sons. The company resisted their attempt to have the shares entered in its register (joint reasons of Mason, Deane and Dawson JJ, [1]-[2]; Wilson J, [6]).

Why good intentions were not enough

Charles believed his sons would manage the company better.

The majority accepted that he need not have acted from purely selfish motives. But believing a decision would help the company did not cure an improper use of the share-allotment power.

The company’s rules gave Charles the board’s powers. They did not free him from the limits attached to those powers.

The majority distinguished creating an initial voting structure from using later allotments to defeat established voting rights (joint judgment [7]-[10]).

What did the court decide?

The High Court dismissed the sons’ appeal by three judges to two, with costs. They did not obtain the order they sought to change the share register.

The majority held that an otherwise valid allotment made for an improper purpose was voidable: it could be set aside, rather than being automatically void. There was no evidence of effective ratification.

Wilson and Brennan JJ dissented. They would have allowed the appeal (joint judgment [11]-[13]; dissenting reasons and final order).

Does any change in voting power make a share issue improper?

No. A share issue can affect voting power without being made for an improper purpose. The reason for using the power matters.

The majority also recognised that a company’s rules and special circumstances could affect the analysis. Its decision was not a blanket ban on share issues that change control.

Where proper and improper purposes overlap, the analysis becomes more complex. The majority discussed a possible test but did not finally settle its precise form because this case did not require it.

Today, section 181(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 separately requires directors and other officers to exercise their powers in good faith in the corporation’s best interests and for a proper purpose (joint judgment [6]-[10]).

Questions to ask your lawyer

If a proposed share issue could change control, ask:

  • What purpose does the share issue serve, and what evidence supports it?

  • What do the company’s rules and existing share rights permit?

  • If the allotment is challenged, what remedy could the court grant?

By Nicky Wang
Principal Solicitor
Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

Misleading conduct: Can you prove it caused your loss?

Next
Next

Can the majority force you to sell your shares?