Home > Case Law Library > Contract > Pacific Carriers Ltd v BNP Paribas [2004] HCA 35Published: 27 January 2025 | Reviewed: 8 October 2026
(3-minute read)
A business may intend only to confirm a customer’s signature. The recipient may understand that the business has promised to cover a loss.
In Pacific Carriers Ltd v BNP Paribas [2004] HCA 35, that gap led to a dispute over both the meaning of signed documents and the bank employee’s authority.
The bank said it was only checking signatures
Pacific Carriers was asked to release cargo without the original bills of lading. It required letters of indemnity: promises to cover losses caused by releasing the goods.
The grain trader, NEAT, signed two letters. A BNP employee also signed them in the space marked “Banker’s signature” and added the bank’s stamp. Neither letter stated that the bank was only checking NEAT’s signatures.
Pacific released cargo in reliance on the letters. It later suffered losses, and NEAT became insolvent. Pacific sought payment from BNP under the indemnities. BNP denied that it had agreed to cover those losses. [3]-[4], [11]-[17]
Meaning depends on what was communicated
The employee believed she was signing only to verify NEAT’s signatures. That limit was never communicated to Pacific.
The High Court assessed what a reasonable person in Pacific’s position would have understood. It considered the wording, the surrounding circumstances known to both parties and the transaction’s purpose.
Pacific had required the bank’s backing before accepting the risk of releasing cargo. Nothing in the letters limited BNP’s role to checking signatures. Read in that context, the documents meant that BNP also promised to indemnify Pacific. [21]-[25]
Internal authority was a separate question
A document may express a promise on behalf of a business, yet the person signing it may lack authority to make that promise.
Here, the employee had no actual authority to bind BNP to an indemnity. The next question was whether the bank’s conduct nevertheless gave her apparent authority.
An employee cannot create that authority merely by claiming to have it. The appearance must come from the business. The Court therefore examined BNP’s conduct as a whole. [29]-[30], [36]-[38]
The bank had helped create the appearance
BNP had placed the employee in charge of its Documentary Credit Department. She was the appropriate person to receive and deal with the request, and she had access to the bank’s stamp.
The bank allowed her to sign and send the letters without an internal check on their final form. It had no procedure ensuring that the limited purpose of its signature was made clear to Pacific.
Pacific reasonably relied on the documents as carrying BNP’s indemnity. The Court held that the bank had induced and assisted that assumption and could not fairly depart from it. The result rested on those circumstances, rather than the signature or stamp alone. [40]-[44]
Pacific won on liability, but damages remained unresolved
The High Court allowed Pacific’s appeal and held that its contract claim succeeded. It returned the matter to the NSW Court of Appeal to decide outstanding issues, including the calculation of damages. [45]-[46]
Make the signing role clear before sending
The practical lesson is to align internal authority with what a document communicates to its recipient.
If a business signs only to verify another person’s signature, that limited role should be clear in the document. Internal instructions may not protect the business where its outward conduct gives a different impression.
By Nicky Wang
Principal Solicitor
