When poor advice is not a breach of loyalty

Home > Case Law Library > Contract > Pilmer v The Duke Group Ltd (in liq) [2001] HCA 31 (Appeal from SA)

Published: 28 January 2025 | Reviewed: 8 October 2026
(3-minute read)

Careless professional work can support a claim without proving a breach of fiduciary duty. In Pilmer, the High Court distinguished the duty to do work with care from obligations of loyalty.

The takeover report

Kia Ora, later called The Duke Group, hired accountants to report on the fairness of a proposed takeover price. Some directors had interests in both companies. The stock exchange rules required a report from an independent, qualified person before shareholders voted.

The accountants said the price was fair and reasonable. At trial, they conceded that their report had been prepared incompetently and in breach of their duty of care. The trial judge also found that they had failed to meet the contractual requirement of independence. [1]-[10], [80]

Why the fiduciary claim failed

A fiduciary duty concerns loyalty. It restricts conflicts and unauthorised gains within the scope of the relationship.

The majority found no relevant fiduciary duty here. The accountants had been retained to value the target company and report on the price. They had not undertaken to advise Kia Ora whether it should pursue the takeover. Reliance on their skill and independence did not, in these circumstances, establish a fiduciary relationship. [69]-[75]

Nor did past business ties and a general hope of future work establish the alleged conflict. The majority required the competing duty or interest to be identified. It found no demonstrated real or substantial possibility of conflict. [80]-[83]

Kirby J disagreed. He considered that the reporting role and the accountants’ associations gave rise to fiduciary duties which they breached by accepting the work. His view did not prevail. [137]-[147]

The appeal did not erase the negligence

The appeal also concerned how to measure the company’s loss. The majority rejected the inclusion of the market value of newly issued shares in damages on the case presented. It distinguished the company’s loss from the effect on its shareholders.

The Court allowed the appeal and sent the matter back to the South Australian Full Court. The accountants’ success did not undo the established breach of their duty of care. [18], [44]-[65], [92]

Questions for your lawyer

The practical starting point is the work the adviser undertook and the duty said to have been broken. This decision does not mean that accountants can never owe fiduciary duties.

  • What did the adviser agree to do for me?

  • Does the evidence show careless work, a breach of contract, a breach of fiduciary duty, or more than one?

  • If a conflict is alleged, what competing duty or interest can we identify?

By Nicky Wang
Principal Solicitor
Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

Lost business opportunities: what was the chance worth?

Next
Next

When can an employee’s signature bind a business?