The fee on your invoice may not show everything an adviser earns from a transaction.
In Wingecarribee Shire Council v Lehman Brothers Australia Ltd (in liq) [2012] FCA 1028, the Federal Court examined an adviser that also sold investments to its clients.
What happened?
Wingecarribee, Parkes and Swan councils wanted secure investments for public money. They dealt with Grange Securities, later renamed Lehman Brothers Australia.
Grange recommended or bought complex financial products for them. When financial conditions worsened, some investments lost value and the products became difficult to sell. The councils sued. [1]
What had the councils agreed to?
For Swan’s earlier dealings and Parkes’ dealings, the councils knew Grange was selling products to them and making money. But they were not told the amounts it earned from the sales.
The Court found that this general knowledge did not amount to fully informed consent to Grange’s benefits and conflicts of interest in those dealings. [2]
The portfolio-management agreements for Swan and Wingecarribee were different. They allowed certain placement fees paid by product issuers, with details available on request. Receiving those authorised fees was not, by itself, a breach.
Those terms did not remove all Grange’s duties. The Court still found breaches under those arrangements. [3]
What did the Court decide?
Justice Rares found Grange liable to compensate the councils for losses from the investments. The findings included breaches of fiduciary duties: duties restricting unauthorised benefits and conflicts of interest. The precise orders were left for a later stage. [4]
The practical lesson
Knowing that an adviser makes money is not always the same as agreeing to how they make it.
This case concerned particular financial advice, contracts and investments. It does not mean every adviser owes the same duties or every payment from a product provider is unlawful.
Questions to ask your lawyer
Which fees, profits or other benefits do my documents allow the adviser to receive?
What further explanation, consent or independent advice is needed before I agree to the transaction?

