Can an arbitration clause cover a challenge to the deed itself?

Home > Case Law Library > Contract > Rinehart v Hancock Prospecting Pty Ltd [2019] HCA 13

Published: 3 February 2025 | Reviewed: 8 October 2026
(3-minute read)

A dispute clause deserves attention before you sign a deed. It may govern where you must bring a later claim that you should not be bound by that deed.

What was the dispute?

Bianca Rinehart and John Hancock brought court proceedings against Gina Rinehart, Hancock Prospecting and others. They alleged wrongdoing involving family trust assets. No findings on those allegations had been made. [2]-[5]

They had signed deeds containing releases of claims and clauses for confidential dispute resolution. They argued that misconduct had led them to sign and sought declarations that the deeds were void against them. [8]-[11]

The question was whether those challenges fell within the arbitration clauses. Arbitration is a process in which an arbitrator, rather than a court, decides a dispute.

Why did the clauses cover the challenges?

The Hope Downs Deed referred to “any dispute under this deed”. The High Court read those words in the context of the deed as a whole, its background and its purpose. [10], [26], [43]-[48]

Confidentiality was central. The deeds sought to settle existing disputes and protect commercial dealings from further public conflict. The Court reasoned that the parties would not have intended challenges to the deeds themselves to be heard publicly while other disputes went through confidential processes. [28]-[49]

All five judges agreed that the validity challenges fell within the clauses. The appeals were dismissed with costs, leaving the court proceedings stayed for arbitration. A stay pauses proceedings; it does not decide who is right about the underlying claims. [17], [50], [81], [83]

What about companies that had not signed?

On a separate cross-appeal, a four-judge majority held that three companies could rely on the arbitration agreement under the NSW legislation. Their defences depended on rights of parties to that agreement. Edelman J disagreed on this issue. This was not a ruling that every related company can enforce an arbitration clause. [56]-[79], [84]-[104]

What should you check before signing?

The practical lesson is to review the dispute process alongside the rights you give up. Do not assume that alleging misconduct will let you bypass an arbitration clause.

Ask your lawyer:

  • Could this clause cover a claim that I was misled or pressured into signing?

  • Who else could rely on it?

  • What would the agreed process mean for cost, confidentiality and review of the outcome?

The result depends on the clause, the agreement and the applicable law. This judgment does not establish that every challenge must go to arbitration. [18]-[26]

By Nicky Wang
Principal Solicitor
Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

What does your adviser earn from the advice you follow?

Next
Next

Burger King v Hungry Jack’s: when approval powers block performance