What does your adviser’s contract leave out?

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Citigroup Global Markets Australia Pty Limited (No 4) [2007] FCA 963.

Before you hire a business adviser, ask what duties the agreement excludes. The title “adviser” may not tell you the whole story.

One bank, two roles

Toll engaged Citigroup to advise on a takeover of Patrick. Another part of Citigroup bought Patrick shares for the bank’s own account before the bid was announced. ASIC challenged the bank’s handling of conflicts and alleged insider trading. [11]-[33]

The engagement letter said Citigroup acted as an independent contractor, not as a fiduciary. A fiduciary duty concerns loyalty, including limits on acting where personal interests conflict with duties to the client. [145], [289]-[292]

Why the contract mattered

The Federal Court upheld that exclusion. ASIC had based its claim to a fiduciary relationship on the engagement letter and expressly did not allege that such a relationship arose before it was signed. That confined the case the Court had to decide. [306]-[307], [324]-[348]

The Court dismissed ASIC’s application. Its conflicts claims depended on a fiduciary relationship that the letter excluded. The insider trading claims also failed, for separate reasons. [599]-[605]

What the decision does not mean

This was an investment-bank engagement involving an experienced corporate client. The Court distinguished solicitor-client relationships and cases where fiduciary duties already existed before the agreement. It did not give every adviser a general right to avoid duties by adding a label to a contract. [297]-[307], [355]-[361]

Nor did the ruling mean that internal information barriers remove every conflict. Citigroup succeeded in its information-barrier defence to the second insider trading claim, but the Court warned about the barriers’ practical limits. [310]-[314], [579]-[604]

Questions for your lawyer

Before signing an adviser’s engagement terms, ask:

  • What duties does this agreement exclude or limit?

  • Can the adviser act for others, or for itself, in the same transaction?

  • What protection remains if our interests differ?

Check the duties, not just the job title.

Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

Owning the company does not remove your duties as a director

Next
Next

Before you guarantee a loan, what should the advice cover?