Cassimatis v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2020] FCAFC 52 (Australian corporations law)
If you own all the shares, you may see a company’s risks as yours to take. But your role as owner does not let you waive your duties as a director.
What happened
Emmanuel and Julie Cassimatis owned all the shares in Storm Financial. They were also directors and exercised extensive control over its business.
Storm advised clients to borrow against their homes and use further loans to invest in share funds. The case concerned advice to 11 financially vulnerable investors. They were retired or nearing retirement, had limited income and assets, and had little or no prospect of recovering from a large loss. [10]-[13], [20], [33]-[44].
The directors argued that Storm was solvent and that, as its owners, they were entitled to choose its level of risk. [119]-[123].
Why ownership was not enough
By a two-to-one majority, the Court dismissed their appeal against findings that they had breached their duty of care and diligence under section 180(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).
The majority examined their own conduct, their control over Storm and the foreseeable risk to the company. The inappropriate advice exposed Storm to serious regulatory risks, including possible loss of its financial services licence. Reasonable directors in their position would have taken steps to prevent that advice. [172]-[181], [495]-[500].
Shareholder approval could not excuse conduct that fell below the statutory standard. [194]-[197].
Rares J dissented on the directors’ liability. He agreed that Storm’s breaches had been established, but considered that ASIC had not proved its case against the directors. [216]-[218], [286]-[287].
What the decision does not mean
A company’s breach of the law does not automatically make its directors liable. Their conduct must be assessed against the care and diligence required in their circumstances. Taking a business risk, or suffering a loss, is not enough by itself. [178]-[183], [429]-[430].
This was a case about directors’ duties in a tightly controlled financial advice business. It was not an order compensating the investors. The advice rules considered were those that applied at the time. [162], [314]-[323].
The High Court dismissed the application for special leave to appeal on 5 August 2020. That left the Full Court’s decision in place; it was not a further appeal judgment on the merits.
Questions to ask your lawyer
What foreseeable harm could this decision cause the company?
How do the likely benefits compare with the risks and the steps available to reduce them?
Does our proposed approval address the legal duty, or only record the owners’ wishes?

