Before you guarantee a loan, what should the advice cover?

Lessons from Stubbings v Jams 2 Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 6.

A certificate of independent advice did not shield the lenders from a finding of unconscionable conduct in this case. The question was what their agent knew about the guarantor’s vulnerability and whether they exploited it.

Stubbings v Jams 2 Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 6 was decided by the High Court of Australia on 16 March 2022, on appeal from Victoria.

The loan put three properties at risk

Mr Stubbings wanted to buy a home. He had no regular income and little financial understanding. His company, which had no assets and had never traded, borrowed money. He guaranteed its debts and gave mortgages over two properties he owned and the home he was buying. [2], [7]-[16]

He expected to sell the two existing properties and refinance the remaining debt with a bank. But the plan could not work. The company defaulted after two monthly interest payments. [24], [50]; Steward J at [134]-[139]

The certificates did not answer the real problem

The lenders’ solicitor arranged the loan through an intermediary. He appreciated that the transaction was dangerous for Mr Stubbings and that Mr Stubbings was vulnerable. [43]-[47], [50]-[51]

The lenders relied on certificates of independent legal and financial advice. Yet the certificates gave no indication that Mr Stubbings had considered how the loans would be serviced. They could not erase the solicitor’s appreciation of the danger and vulnerability. [48]-[49]

Steward J also explained that neither certificate addressed the company’s or Mr Stubbings’ ability to service the loans. The financial certificate concerned advice to the company, not to Mr Stubbings as guarantor. [170]-[173]

What the High Court decided

The High Court allowed Mr Stubbings’ appeal. Kiefel CJ, Keane and Gleeson JJ held that the lenders, through their agent, had unconscientiously exploited his special disadvantage. It was unconscionable for them to insist on their rights under the mortgages. [52]-[53]

Steward J reached the same result in equity. Gordon J separately found that the lending system, and the dealings with Mr Stubbings, also breached the statutory prohibition on unconscionable conduct. [54], [84], [94]-[95], [169]-[174]

What this means before you sign

A certificate of advice is no substitute for advice that addresses your actual risk.

Before giving a guarantee, ask your own lawyer:

  • What must I pay if the borrower cannot pay, and which assets are at risk?

  • Does the advice address my position as guarantor, separately from the borrower’s?

  • What financial advice do I need to test whether the repayment and refinancing plan can work?

These are practical questions drawn from the case. The decision does not make every risky loan unconscionable or every advice certificate ineffective. Equitable relief depends on special disadvantage, the other party’s knowledge and exploitation of that disadvantage-not simply a bad bargain. [4], [38]-[42]

Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

What does your adviser’s contract leave out?

Next
Next

Can a fee be a penalty without a contract breach?