Can a fee be a penalty without a contract breach?

A fee may be open to challenge as a penalty even if you have not broken the contract.

Andrews v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2012] HCA 30.

That was the point decided in Andrews v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2012] HCA 30. It did not mean the bank’s fees were invalid.

Why the customers appealed

ANZ customers challenged fees charged for events such as payments exceeding an account’s funds or credit limit.

The trial judge held that certain fees were not charged for a breach of contract. She treated that finding, together with the absence of a duty to avoid the relevant events, as excluding a penalty challenge. The customers appealed. [19]-[23]

What the High Court decided

The High Court unanimously rejected that restriction. The law against penalties could apply beyond a breach of contract. [45]-[50], [78], [84]

The substance of the arrangement mattered. The Court described a penalty as an added burden attached to another term to secure its fulfilment. But an agreed charge for an extra service or facility could have a different character. The contract had to be examined to tell the difference. [10], [79]-[82]

The Court allowed the appeal. It left the actual character of the disputed fees for further trial. Winning this legal point did not establish a right to repayment. [83]-[86] hcourt.gov.au

What this means for a fee dispute

The first question is what the fee does under the contract. Its trigger alone does not settle whether it is a penalty.

A later case, Paciocco v ANZ [2016] HCA 28, addressed the separate question of whether credit card late fees were penalties. The majority rejected that challenge. Andrews does not make every large or unwelcome fee unlawful. [Paciocco: orders; French CJ at [2]-[5]; Kiefel J at [69]]

Questions for your lawyer

  • What does this fee secure, or what extra service or facility does it pay for?

  • What terms and evidence would support a penalty challenge?

  • Are there other legal grounds to challenge it?

Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Next
Next

Can financial advice be personal despite a general advice warning?