You lend money after reading a company’s audited accounts. The company fails. You believe the audit was careless. Can you recover your loss from the auditor?
Relying on audited accounts does not, by itself, mean the auditor owes you a duty of care.
That distinction was central to Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Peat Marwick Hungerfords (Reg) [1997] HCA 8; (1997) 188 CLR 241. The High Court of Australia decided the appeal on 18 March 1997. It arose from proceedings in South Australia.
What happened?
Esanda provided finance in transactions involving Excel Finance and related companies. It alleged that it relied on Excel’s audited accounts, that the auditors had been negligent and that it suffered financial loss. Those allegations had not been proved at a trial. [1-6], [17-19]
The appeal concerned whether the facts in Esanda’s written claim could establish that the auditors owed it a duty of care: a legal obligation to take reasonable care towards it. [35-36]
Why the claim fell short
Esanda relied on the argument that the auditors could foresee that creditors and financiers might use the accounts. That was not enough. The accounting standards it cited did not fill the gap: identifying likely users of accounts did not itself create a duty to those users. [6-8], [20-21]
The claim did not allege that Esanda had asked the auditors for advice, that they knew of its proposed transactions, or that they knew the accounts would be passed to it for that purpose. [39]
The High Court dismissed the appeal with costs. The order striking out the challenged parts of the claim stood. This was a decision about the claim as pleaded, not a finding that the audit had been carried out carefully. [16], [32], [58], [135], [191-201]; orders
What this means before you lend
The decision does not mean auditors can never owe duties to people other than their clients. The circumstances of the relationship matter. Nor did the judges treat an intention to induce reliance as essential in every case. [25-27], [53-55], [195-196]
The practical lesson is to clarify the basis for relying on someone else’s audit before committing money. Ask your lawyer:
What facts would show that the auditor owes me a duty for this transaction?
Should I seek advice or confirmation addressed to me for this purpose?
What further checks should I arrange?
These are practical questions prompted by the case, not a checklist that guarantees a claim.

