ABN AMRO Bank NV v Bathurst Regional Council [2014] FCAFC 65You may rely on an expert opinion passed to you by someone else. In this case, the court found that the expert owed investors a duty of care despite having no contract with them. The purpose of the opinion and the expected reliance mattered. [1259]-[1271]
What happened
ABN Amro created a complex investment called the Rembrandt notes. Standard & Poor’s (S&P) gave the notes its highest credit rating: AAA. Local Government Financial Services bought notes and sold some to 13 NSW councils. The councils lost much of their investment. [1]-[2]
The Full Court upheld findings that S&P’s rating was misleading and involved negligent misrepresentations. The rating conveyed that S&P had reasonable grounds for its opinion and had used reasonable care and skill. Neither was true. [12(1)]
Why the lack of a contract did not settle the issue
ABN Amro paid S&P for the rating. But S&P knew the rating would be passed to potential investors to help them decide whether to invest. The councils were within that identifiable group. S&P did not need to know each investor’s name. [1260]-[1262], [1270]-[1271]
The court also found that the councils could not reproduce S&P’s specialist assessment of the credit risk. Reading the available report would not have exposed the faulty rating or all the relevant risks. [1265]-[1268]
What the decision does not mean
S&P’s duty was to use reasonable care in forming and expressing its opinion about the notes’ credit risk. It was not a promise to prevent every investment loss. An opinion turning out to be wrong was not, by itself, the failure identified here. [566], [1266]
This decision does not make every expert responsible to everyone who reads their work. The intended use, the people expected to rely on it and whether that reliance was reasonable all mattered. [573]-[578]
The practical lesson: No contract does not always mean no duty of care.
Questions to ask your lawyer
Was this opinion prepared for people in my position to use for this purpose?
What evidence shows that I relied on it and that it caused my loss?
Do any disclaimers limit the responsibility I am assuming the expert accepted?

