Australian Securities and Investments Commission v RI Advice Group Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 496If your business holds client data across several offices, how do you know each office follows your security rules?
In this case, a financial services licensee had policies and training. But it admitted that its systems were inadequate and that putting better measures into practice took too long.
What went wrong
RI Advice authorised independently owned practices to provide financial services under its licence. Those practices held sensitive client data, including identity documents and financial details. Nine cyber incidents occurred between June 2014 and May 2020. [1]-[4], [13]-[16]
Problems included shared passwords, outdated antivirus software and missing backups. RI Advice already had security standards, training and an incident reporting process. [17]-[19]
Yet, before 15 May 2018, its checks on compliance with its standards went little beyond asking representatives to confirm they had read and knew about them. From that date until 5 August 2021, it lacked adequate audit and compliance processes to check whether the cyber rules were understood and followed, and to bring gaps to management’s attention. Annexure A, [18]
RI Advice made substantial improvements. It still accepted that it should have put the measures in place across its practices sooner. [21]-[24]
What the Court decided
The parties settled the case. The Federal Court made declarations and orders based on agreed facts and RI Advice’s admissions. [7]-[10]
The Court found that, from 15 May 2018 to 5 August 2021, RI Advice breached sections 912A(1)(a) and (h) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Its failures concerned the efficient and fair provision of financial services and adequate risk management systems. No dishonesty was alleged. [51]-[52], [65]-[66]
RI Advice had to engage a cyber expert to identify any further measures needed, arrange their implementation and report to ASIC. It also had to pay $750,000 towards ASIC’s legal costs. That payment was a costs contribution, not a fine. Orders 3-6
What this means for a business owner
The practical lesson is to assign responsibility, set deadlines and check completion.
This is a lesson drawn from the case, rather than a rule imposed on every business.
The decision concerned financial services licence duties. It did not set one cyber checklist for all businesses. The Court explained that the right measures depend on the business’s risks and IT systems, informed by technical expertise. It also recognised that cyber risk cannot be reduced to zero. [46]-[49], [55], [58]
Questions for your lawyer
Which legal duties apply to the client data our business holds?
What records would help show that we put suitable safeguards in place and checked their use?

