Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Kobelt [2019] HCA 18 (Australian federal financial services law; conduct in South Australia)A harsh deal alone does not prove unconscionable conduct.
The court must assess the conduct in its full setting. In this case, seven High Court judges reached a closely divided result.
The storekeeper held the bank cards
Mr Kobelt ran a general store in remote South Australia. He offered “book-up”: customers could take goods now and pay later. The customers in ASIC’s case were Anangu people from remote communities. They had low incomes and limited financial literacy.
Customers handed over their bank cards and PINs. Mr Kobelt withdrew all or nearly all of the money in their accounts when wages or benefits arrived. At least half went towards their debt. The remainder was available through his store, cash advances or purchase orders, subject to his control. His records were poor and customers received no account statements. ([20]-[31])
ASIC argued that the system took advantage of the customers’ vulnerability and made them dependent on the store.
ASIC lost the appeal by four votes to three
The trial judge found the system unconscionable. The Full Federal Court overturned that finding. The High Court dismissed ASIC’s appeal with costs. ([7]-[13]; orders)
Kiefel CJ and Bell J found that customers understood the basic system and chose it for benefits that included access to credit. They concluded that Mr Kobelt had not exploited the customers’ lack of education or financial skills. ([65]-[79])
Gageler J gave weight to the customers’ choices and the evidence about their needs and cultural practices. Keane J found that ASIC had not shown that Mr Kobelt exploited their vulnerability to extract a financial advantage. Both agreed that the appeal should fail. ([108]-[115])
Three judges saw exploitation
Nettle and Gordon JJ considered that the system left customers dependent on Mr Kobelt’s discretion for basic needs. In their view, voluntary participation and some benefits did not excuse the exploitation. Edelman J agreed that the appeal should succeed. ([157]-[161], [205]-[207], [268])
What the decision does, and does not, show
The majority’s result concerned this system and the case ASIC presented. It did not approve every book-up arrangement. Nor does consent alone rule out unconscionable conduct: Kiefel CJ and Bell J expressly recognised that a person may enter a contract voluntarily and still face such conduct. ([48], [58], [78]-[79])
The finding that Mr Kobelt had engaged in unlicensed credit activity remained in place. Winning on unconscionability did not clear him of that separate breach. ([7], [51])
The statutory rules also extend beyond the older equitable doctrine. Current section 12CB permits scrutiny of a system without identifying a particular person disadvantaged by it. In the later Productivity Partners case, Gordon J explained, under the Australian Consumer Law, that special disadvantage of an individual is not a necessary component of the statutory prohibition. The applicable law and facts still need to be checked.
Questions to ask your lawyer
Which law applies to this credit arrangement?
What evidence shows how it worked, including control of money, charges and practical choices?
Could another legal claim apply even if unconscionable conduct is not proved?

