When can a bank’s loan terms be unfair?

A clear loan term can still be unfair.
The issue is what it lets the bank do, assessed in the context of the whole contract: [13], [31], [35]–[36].

In Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Limited [2020] FCA 716, the Federal Court of Australia examined terms in standard form small-business loans used by the bank’s Delphi Bank and Rural Bank divisions. Justice Gleeson gave judgment on 28 May 2020 under federal law: [1]-[6], [42]-[47].

What powers did the terms give the bank?

The challenged clauses fell into four groups:

  • Passing losses to the borrower. The borrower could have to cover losses they did not cause, including losses caused by the bank’s own mistakes or negligence: [49]-[56].

  • Calling a default. Severe consequences could follow minor errors or events that posed no credit risk to the bank, without a right to fix a breach that could be fixed: [58]-[65].

  • Changing or ending the loan. The bank could change terms or reduce available funds without matching rights for the borrower. Notice might leave too little time to refinance, while leaving could trigger fees: [66]-[74].

  • Making the borrower disprove its figures. A bank certificate could shift the burden of proof to the borrower, although the bank was best placed to provide the underlying evidence: [75]-[81].

What made them unfair?

The legal test had three parts. The term had to:

  1. create a significant imbalance in the parties’ rights and duties;

  2. go beyond what was reasonably needed to protect the legitimate interests of the party it favoured; and

  3. cause financial or other harm if applied or relied on.

The Court had to consider how clearly the term was expressed and presented, and the contract as a whole: [13].

The bank accepted that the challenged terms were unfair. The Court examined them and agreed. It did not find that every challenged term lacked clarity: [1], [65], [81]-[82].

What did the Court order?

The Court declared the challenged terms in six identified contracts unfair and void from the outset. It also replaced some clauses with narrower terms and required an undertaking not to use or rely on the challenged terms: orders [1]-[12], [15]-[21].

ASIC did not allege that the bank had used those terms unfairly or caused customers loss. The orders aimed to prevent harm: [5], [103].

Does this apply to your loan?

This case concerned particular terms in eligible small-business contracts. It does not mean every clause favouring a bank is unfair.

Reforms from 9 November 2023 expanded protection and introduced penalties. Which rules apply depends on the contract, including when it was made, renewed or changed. The 2020 eligibility limits should not be used as today’s rules.

Questions for your lawyer

  • Which unfair contract terms rules cover my loan?

  • What limits protect me if the bank changes terms, calls a default or claims costs?

  • If a term is unfair, what does that mean for my remaining loan duties?

Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

A cyber policy is only a start

Next
Next

Home loan checks: must lenders use your spending figures?