Home loan checks: must lenders use your spending figures?

A lender’s assessment looks ahead. What you spent before taking out a loan may differ from what you can afford to spend once repayments begin.

In Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Westpac Banking Corporation [2020] FCAFC 111, the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia considered how lenders must assess proposed home loans under Commonwealth consumer credit law.

What Westpac did

Westpac used an automated system to assess home loan applications. One calculation used a household spending benchmark, rather than the borrower’s declared living expenses. Another rule compared those declared expenses with income and referred applications for manual assessment if the ratio was too high. [97]-[110].

ASIC argued that Westpac had not made the assessments required by law. It did not allege that any particular loan was unsuitable. Nor did it allege a failure to make the required inquiries under section 130. [3]-[4], [129].

Why the majority rejected ASIC’s case

The appeal was dismissed, with costs, by a two-to-one majority. Justices Gleeson and Lee held that the law did not prescribe the use of declared living expenses in the way ASIC argued. Past spending could include costs a borrower could reduce without substantial hardship. [127]-[144], [167]-[175].

Justice Gleeson also found that Westpac had considered declared expenses through its separate ratio rule. The system had to be considered as a whole. [154]-[160].

Justice Middleton disagreed on the living-expenses issue. He said the lender needed to examine each borrower’s expenses, even if some were later discounted. His view did not prevail. [36]-[38], [62]-[64], [83]-[84].

All three judges rejected ASIC’s separate challenge to the way Westpac calculated repayments for loans with an initial interest-only period. [77]-[82], [87], [164].

What this means for a borrower

A choice of assessment method does not remove the duty to assess your proposed loan.

The decision did not give lenders unrestricted freedom to ignore individual circumstances. They still had to make reasonable inquiries, take reasonable steps to verify the borrower’s financial situation and assess whether the proposed contract would be unsuitable. [131]-[144], [170]-[171].

Those inquiry and verification duties remain separate from the choice of assessment method. The Federal Court reinforced that distinction in ASIC v Money3 Loans Pty Ltd (No 3) [2025] FCA 1086 at [98]-[100].

Questions for your lawyer

  • Is my concern about the lender’s inquiries, its assessment method, or whether my loan was unsuitable?

  • What evidence shows which expenses I could reduce without substantial hardship?

  • Which law applied when I entered the loan?

Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

When can a bank’s loan terms be unfair?

Next
Next

Can an expert owe you a duty if you did not hire them?