Proving fault and recovering your whole loss are different questions.
In Hunt & Hunt Lawyers v Mitchell Morgan Nominees Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 10, the High Court of Australia considered a NSW loan dispute involving fraud and negligent legal work.
A loan with no effective security
Mitchell Morgan lent just over $1 million. Two fraudsters used forged documents and a false solicitor’s certificate to obtain the loan. One withdrew the money using forged cheques. Both were bankrupt by the time the trial was heard. [1]-[2]
The lender’s solicitors, Hunt & Hunt, drafted the loan agreement and mortgage. The forged loan agreement did not bind the property owner. The registered mortgage referred to that agreement, so it secured nothing. The solicitors should have included a promise to repay a stated amount in the mortgage itself. Their negligence was not disputed in the High Court. [3]
Different acts caused the same loss
The trial judge limited the solicitors’ liability to 12.5% of the lender’s loss. The NSW Court of Appeal rejected that division. [7]-[8]
By a 3-2 majority, the High Court restored it. The majority identified the loss as the lender’s inability to recover the money advanced. Both the fraud and the faulty mortgage caused that loss, even though the wrongdoers acted in different ways. [9], [28], [49]-[58]
The two dissenting judges saw the harm differently: the solicitors had left the lender without security, which was distinct from the harm caused by the fraudsters. [100]-[101]
Bankruptcy did not increase the solicitors’ share
Under the NSW proportionate liability rules applied in this case, the fraudsters’ bankruptcy did not make the solicitors responsible for the unpaid balance. The lender bore the risk of being unable to collect from the other wrongdoers. [10], [17]
This did not give the fraudsters the same protection. The legislation did not limit a wrongdoer’s own liability for loss they fraudulently caused. [66]; Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), s 34A.
The decision concerned a claim covered by those rules. It does not mean that liability is divided in every dispute involving several people.
Questions for your lawyer
Could anyone else be legally responsible for the same loss?
Can the defendant’s liability be limited to a share of that loss?
If another wrongdoer cannot pay, what could I realistically recover after legal costs?

