The legal basis of your claim can affect whether a defendant must pay the whole loss or only a share.
The failed investment
Mr and Mrs Selig invested in Neovest on advice from a financial adviser authorised by Wealthsure. The scheme was, in effect, a Ponzi scheme. Neovest became insolvent. The couple lost their investment and suffered further losses. [1]
They won claims against Wealthsure, the adviser and two directors. The defendants sought to limit their liability by dividing responsibility for the loss. [2-7]
Why the type of claim mattered
Under proportionate liability, a defendant's liability can be limited to its share of responsibility. If another person responsible cannot pay, the claimant may bear that shortfall. [21]
The High Court held that the Corporations Act scheme at issue applied only to damages claims based on misleading or deceptive conduct under section 1041H. Other claims did not fall within that scheme merely because they concerned the same loss. [24-37]
Those other claims had to be assessed under the rules that applied to them. The Court allowed the couple's appeal and restored judgment for $1,716,680, without the disputed reductions. [14, 32, 49]
An order to pay is not payment
The Court also ordered Wealthsure's insurer to pay the couple's costs of both appeals. The insurer had pursued the appeal in its own interests. Its legal spending reduced the insurance money available to meet the judgment and costs. [39-48]
This decision concerned particular federal laws. It does not mean every claim avoids proportionate liability. Other laws may apply, and a successful claim does not ensure the money can be recovered. [21, 32, 41; 51-57]
Questions for your lawyer
Which legal claims do the facts support, and can liability be split under each?
If someone responsible cannot pay, how would that affect what I can recover?
What do we know about available assets, insurance and any limit that includes legal costs?

