Who was checking the disclosure issue?

Case: Shafron v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2012] HCA 18 (appeal from NSW concerning corporations law)

When several advisers work on a matter, it helps to know which issues each has agreed to cover.

What happened

Peter Shafron was general counsel and company secretary of James Hardie Industries Ltd. He helped develop a plan to separate two subsidiaries from the group. The plan involved estimates of future asbestos claims. [2], [4], [28]-[31]

Two findings against him were at issue. He had failed to advise the chief executive or board about disclosing information concerning a deed of covenant and indemnity to the Australian Stock Exchange. He had also failed to warn the board about a significant limit in the estimates used for its cash flow model. [3]-[4], [32]

Why his arguments failed

Shafron argued that his duties as company secretary should be separated from his work as general counsel. The High Court rejected that approach. His duty of care depended on his office and actual responsibilities within the company. It was not confined to tasks attached to a job title. [10]-[20]

On disclosure, he argued that he could assume the company's external solicitors would advise him if disclosure was required. But the Court upheld the finding that their engagement did not cover that question, either expressly or by implication. [33]

The estimates raised a different issue. They made no allowance for asbestos claim costs rising faster than general inflation. Shafron knew of that limit and its importance. He should have warned the board that prudence called for an allowance. He did not need to calculate the right rate as an expert actuary. [34]-[35]

The Court dismissed his appeal with costs. [36]-[37], [47]

What readers can take from it

Before relying on another adviser, check that the issue falls within their work.

That is a practical lesson from the facts. The legal ruling concerned Shafron's duties as a company officer. It does not mean every adviser has those duties, or that hiring a specialist removes someone else's responsibilities.

Questions for your lawyer

  • Which issues does each adviser's engagement cover, and who will check any gaps?

  • What assumptions or limits in the expert advice could affect my decision?

  • What responsibilities remain with me despite the advice I obtain?

Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

Can small print correct a headline price?

Next
Next

Before company money goes to a director’s company