Claiming for a building delay? Show what it held up

An expert report may calculate a delay. The evidence still needs to show how it affected the work and caused the loss claimed.

The claim

White Constructions was developing a 100-lot subdivision at Kiama, NSW. It claimed that its sewer designer and water servicing coordinator had delayed the project by failing to secure an acceptable sewer design in time. It sought about $1.94 million. [1]-[9], [186]

In White Constructions Pty Ltd v PBS Holdings Pty Ltd [2019] NSWSC 1166, Hammerschlag J dismissed the claim in the Supreme Court of NSW. White had not proved a breach of contract. Its project manager had instructed the designer not to pursue the deep-boring option that was later approved. [162]-[179], [279]

The judge then considered damages on the assumption that a breach had been proved. That part of the judgment offers a separate lesson about evidence. [181]-[182]

What the reports could not establish

Each side called a delay expert. They used different methods and reached very different conclusions. With help from a specialist adviser, the judge found neither method suitable for this case. He examined what had actually happened on site. [13]-[27], [188]-[201]

The site diary repeatedly recorded waits for sewer approval. But it did not identify which activities those waits had held up. Other work was continuing. Those entries could not establish the claimed consequences. [204]-[212]

White needed to show how the sewer delay affected completion of the whole project. That included whether work could have been moved around or done during waiting periods. It failed to do so. [197]-[199]

Paying a cost did not prove who owed it

White also relied on amounts its project manager had certified as payable to the builder. Those certificates did not bind the designer or coordinator. White still had to prove an actual liability for an actual amount recoverable from them. [230]-[232]

The judge found that White had not proved loss even on the assumed breach. [182]

Before paying for more expert work

Ask your lawyer:

  • Which records show what was held up, for how long, and why?

  • What other causes of delay must our evidence address?

  • Which claimed costs can we link to the alleged breach?

  • What factual gap would another expert report resolve?

The judgment did not reject expert evidence or recognised delay methods generally. The judge assessed the methods and evidence used in this particular dispute. [191], [195]

Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

Missed payment certificate: must the building claim be paid?

Next
Next

Payment for work without a written contract